Integration Concern, the total area of x^3 (1 Viewer)

cloud edwards

Member
Joined
Jan 22, 2016
Messages
84
Location
rural place
Gender
Male
HSC
2017
So i'm stuck with this idea in my head and asked a couple of mates what the area is of the x^3 between x+-1 and x=1.

One of me friends said the area is 0units^2 from following: [x^-4/4] between x=-1 and 1. = 1-1=0.

Another said it was 2 units^2 as he did: [x^-4/4] between x=-1 and 1 using absolute values, so the total was 1+1=2.

I understand how both of me friends came to their conclusion, but i'm still not sure particularly with the thought of the cubic graph having an area of 0 seems weird. So which one is right? By using the absolute value and getting 2units^2 the 0 units.
 

InteGrand

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 11, 2014
Messages
6,109
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
So i'm stuck with this idea in my head and asked a couple of mates what the area is of the x^3 between x+-1 and x=1.

One of me friends said the area is 0units^2 from following: [x^-4/4] between x=-1 and 1. = 1-1=0.

Another said it was 2 units^2 as he did: [x^-4/4] between x=-1 and 1 using absolute values, so the total was 1+1=2.

I understand how both of me friends came to their conclusion, but i'm still not sure particularly with the thought of the cubic graph having an area of 0 seems weird. So which one is right? By using the absolute value and getting 2units^2 the 0 units.
If you want the actual physical area, it's the one using absolute values.

The thing that is 0 is the signed area, or net area.

If we just say "area" of a function on an interval without saying "signed area" or "net area", we would probably be referring to the physical area, which is always positive for a continuous nonzero function.
 
Last edited:

boredofstudiesuser1

Active Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2016
Messages
570
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2018
Following on from what Integrand said, your first friend (0 units) just evaluated the integral, your second friend (2 units) found the area.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top