Chem or Physics? Help! (1 Viewer)

Shutterbug97

New Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
8
Gender
Female
HSC
2014
Hey I need some help choosing between Chem and Physics for Year 11 next year.
I've selected my subjects, but now in hindsight I'm sort of reconsidering my choice of Chem. I've still got heaps of time to change my choice.
I have: Eng (Advanced), SOR (1U), Maths (Advanced), Eng Ext. 1, Biology, Chem, Visual Art.

I sort of just picked Chemistry without thinking, because I've heard that Physics is really hard. We haven't really covered Physics in Year 10. We have done a bit of Chemistry, and i'm pretty fascinated by atoms and molecules and chemistry in the world around us, but i find observations and chemical equations pretty dry. What's Chem like?? Is Physics more interesting? Is Physics worth the work load??

I'm very academic, and I'm very good at maths (top of my class) but i don't enjoy it that much. I want to get a Bachelor of Science with a major of Zoology.

Thoughts??
 

Hoskiies

Member
Joined
Oct 9, 2012
Messages
90
Gender
Male
HSC
2013
If you're willing to keep it until year 12, I'll pick Physics if your person who has a abstract mind, and link all the cause and affect together. It's harder than chemistry but if you can do that ill be easier.
Chemistry has a lot of rote learning like more than half of the syllabus is rote learning equations and other shit. Chems more interest for sure, the practs more fun but there's a load of work for both subjects.
 

TheOptimist

Member
Joined
Sep 24, 2012
Messages
475
Location
__̴ı̴̴̡̡̡ ̡͌l̡̡̡ ̡͌l̡*̡̡ ̴̡ı̴̴̡ ̡̡͡|̲̲̲͡͡͡ ̲▫̲͡ ̲̲
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
Uni Grad
2018
Since you are speaking from both an academic and personal perspective, I'd say you should go with Chemistry, it is a higher scaling subject and if you enjoy it, all the concepts will be easier to comprehend. It might also help you with university level Chemistry which is quite hard, so I hear, without doing any prerequisite subjects in High School. Hope this helps :)
 

probjer

Member
Joined
May 8, 2012
Messages
37
Gender
Female
HSC
2012
stop being a pussy and do both instead of visual arts
 

GoldyOrNugget

Señor Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2012
Messages
583
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
Rant:

I was incredibly disappointed with the physics course. My friends who do chem say the same thing about chemistry. In both subjects, you're required to do an immense amount of memorisation, especially of things like historical scientific developments. A lot of the physics content in the textbook and in past exams is objectively wrong -- neither the textbook writers nor the exam writers seem to understand the actual physics principles at work.

HSC physics isn't hard in the traditional sense. The concepts it deals with, particularly in Ideas to Implementation, are incredibly advanced -- these are concepts which earned physicists Nobel prizes. But the course does not cover them at an advanced level. The result is that you end up with a superficial and deeply flawed knowledge of a large number of concepts. The course is not designed to be understood. It's designed to be rote-learned. Trying to apply logic to the principles in the course will hinder you and cost you marks. For example, in many cases, there will be 2 correct multiple choice answers: a correct one and an "HSC-correct" one.

I went in to physics with the attitude that I took to most subjects (especially maths): if I have a solid understanding of the underlying principles, I should do well. This is not the case with physics. The way to do well in physics, you have to read a list of every syllabus dotpoint and write notes on it. You have to cram your heads with facts that no one fucking cares about, like how Fermi created the first nuclear chain reaction in Chicago in a squash court with 400 tonnes of graphite moderator and cadmium control rods and 60 tonnes of uranium (which was almost all of the US's reserves at the time!)

Feel free to do them. They scale well and probably require less memorisation than a lot of other subjects. But don't think they're gonna be interesting or insightful. That's just not what the HSC is about. The HSC takes everything that has any potential to be good and rips it to shreds and then pieces it back together again into a grotesque puppet of what it once was.

/ goes back to studying physics
 

madharris

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2011
Messages
2,160
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
Do chemistry if you want to major in zoology
 

Shadowless

Member
Joined
May 3, 2010
Messages
342
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
Rant:

I was incredibly disappointed with the physics course. My friends who do chem say the same thing about chemistry. In both subjects, you're required to do an immense amount of memorisation, especially of things like historical scientific developments. A lot of the physics content in the textbook and in past exams is objectively wrong -- neither the textbook writers nor the exam writers seem to understand the actual physics principles at work.

HSC physics isn't hard in the traditional sense. The concepts it deals with, particularly in Ideas to Implementation, are incredibly advanced -- these are concepts which earned physicists Nobel prizes. But the course does not cover them at an advanced level. The result is that you end up with a superficial and deeply flawed knowledge of a large number of concepts. The course is not designed to be understood. It's designed to be rote-learned. Trying to apply logic to the principles in the course will hinder you and cost you marks. For example, in many cases, there will be 2 correct multiple choice answers: a correct one and an "HSC-correct" one.

I went in to physics with the attitude that I took to most subjects (especially maths): if I have a solid understanding of the underlying principles, I should do well. This is not the case with physics. The way to do well in physics, you have to read a list of every syllabus dotpoint and write notes on it. You have to cram your heads with facts that no one fucking cares about, like how Fermi created the first nuclear chain reaction in Chicago in a squash court with 400 tonnes of graphite moderator and cadmium control rods and 60 tonnes of uranium (which was almost all of the US's reserves at the time!)

Feel free to do them. They scale well and probably require less memorisation than a lot of other subjects. But don't think they're gonna be interesting or insightful. That's just not what the HSC is about. The HSC takes everything that has any potential to be good and rips it to shreds and then pieces it back together again into a grotesque puppet of what it once was.

/ goes back to studying physics
Apparently the old physics was WAAY better. Was less 'memorising' and more 'understanding'... like Maths!
 

Shutterbug97

New Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
8
Gender
Female
HSC
2014
Rant:

I was incredibly disappointed with the physics course. My friends who do chem say the same thing about chemistry. In both subjects, you're required to do an immense amount of memorisation, especially of things like historical scientific developments. A lot of the physics content in the textbook and in past exams is objectively wrong -- neither the textbook writers nor the exam writers seem to understand the actual physics principles at work.

HSC physics isn't hard in the traditional sense. The concepts it deals with, particularly in Ideas to Implementation, are incredibly advanced -- these are concepts which earned physicists Nobel prizes. But the course does not cover them at an advanced level. The result is that you end up with a superficial and deeply flawed knowledge of a large number of concepts. The course is not designed to be understood. It's designed to be rote-learned. Trying to apply logic to the principles in the course will hinder you and cost you marks. For example, in many cases, there will be 2 correct multiple choice answers: a correct one and an "HSC-correct" one.

I went in to physics with the attitude that I took to most subjects (especially maths): if I have a solid understanding of the underlying principles, I should do well. This is not the case with physics. The way to do well in physics, you have to read a list of every syllabus dotpoint and write notes on it. You have to cram your heads with facts that no one fucking cares about, like how Fermi created the first nuclear chain reaction in Chicago in a squash court with 400 tonnes of graphite moderator and cadmium control rods and 60 tonnes of uranium (which was almost all of the US's reserves at the time!)

Feel free to do them. They scale well and probably require less memorisation than a lot of other subjects. But don't think they're gonna be interesting or insightful. That's just not what the HSC is about. The HSC takes everything that has any potential to be good and rips it to shreds and then pieces it back together again into a grotesque puppet of what it once was.

/ goes back to studying physics
Haha that was an awesome rant. Physics just pwned
 

Riproot

#MedLyf
Joined
Nov 10, 2009
Messages
8,228
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
Uni Grad
2017
Chemistry is more helpful.

Honestly, as soon as you get to doing some sort of science or something you realise that you don't need to have done bio or physics as long as you've done well in chemistry and then just use that knowledge to do both physics and bio.

(but also you need MX2 for physics)
 

Riproot

#MedLyf
Joined
Nov 10, 2009
Messages
8,228
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
Uni Grad
2017
If you're the top of your class in Maths you should do extension one or two, without AT LEAST extension one you may feel behind everyone at uni mathematically.
 

Shutterbug97

New Member
Joined
Oct 17, 2012
Messages
8
Gender
Female
HSC
2014
If you're the top of your class in Maths you should do extension one or two, without AT LEAST extension one you may feel behind everyone at uni mathematically.
Yeah I'm good at maths and i top my class but i really work my arse off to be there. How challenging is Ext 1??
 

Shadowless

Member
Joined
May 3, 2010
Messages
342
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
Yeah I'm good at maths and i top my class but i really work my arse off to be there. How challenging is Ext 1??
- Gap between Advanced Mathematics and Mathematics Extension 1 is very minor.
- Seeing as you're already at the top of your class, you seem to have potential to do the course and I recommend you do.
- You can always drop it if you find it too challenging.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top