Earth travelling through space - we can/cannot feel it? (1 Viewer)

Sanical

SpiderAnderson
Joined
Sep 7, 2011
Messages
499
Location
In the middle of Little Italy
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
We can’t feel ourselves move through space since we are always at a constant velocity (I think around 100 000km/s) so based on our frame of reference, we can consider ourselves stationary.
However, according to Kepler’s second law, we move faster when the Earth is closer to the sun due to its greater gravitational attraction. If we move faster, that means we would accelerate. If we are accelerating, why can’t we feel it? Wouldn't we feel the reaction force? The acceleration can’t be that insignificant that we cannot feel it?

Help?
 

jamesfirst

Active Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2010
Messages
2,020
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
Wait. If the Earth is orbiting in a circular motion around the sun (or oval... idk), wouldn't it be accelerating due to centripetal force (centripetal acceleration) ?
 

cheezcake

Callipygian Member
Joined
Mar 14, 2010
Messages
596
Location
Gliese 581 d
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
It is, but the gravitational acceleration due to the earth far outweighs the negligible acceleration due to centripetal force, so we don't feel it, at least that's a possibility
 

jamesfirst

Active Member
Joined
Jan 30, 2010
Messages
2,020
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
Yeah, because last time I fucking checked, this section didn't relate to the syllabus


no need to be fucking rude, idiot.
 
Last edited:

hayabusaboston

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2011
Messages
2,387
Location
Calabi Yau Manifold
Gender
Male
HSC
2013
Hypocrisy and irony at its finest :) Nice to know that people can't extend their knowledge past the scope of the syllabus.
So what was your problem again? That you don't understand how we can't feel the extra acceleration? In terms of our size on the Earth we need a MASSIVE acceleration before we become conscious of it, consider our speed without acceleration, approx 107,400km/h on average and relate that to the Astronomical Unit (149,598,000 km). The AU is 1400 times bigger. Now that is a HUGE difference, only an absolutely enormous acceleration would be felt by us, because of that difference, which is even small in the solar system, and our own size on Earth. Im not going to guess the acceleration required because I dont know, and everyone has different proprioceptive adaptations which allow them to feel different stimuli at different intensities, so it would be extremely difficult to extrapolate an accurate reading of "vestibular proprioception" for the general population.
 
Last edited:

hayabusaboston

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2011
Messages
2,387
Location
Calabi Yau Manifold
Gender
Male
HSC
2013
Man I recommend you read "A Brief History Of Time" By Stephen Hawking. Very good book and explains a lot if you want to know more about that kind of stuff.
 

_deloso

Member
Joined
Jan 25, 2011
Messages
470
Location
Andromeda Galaxy
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
We can’t feel ourselves move through space since we are always at a constant velocity (I think around 100 000km/s) so based on our frame of reference, we can consider ourselves stationary.
However, according to Kepler’s second law, we move faster when the Earth is closer to the sun due to its greater gravitational attraction. If we move faster, that means we would accelerate. If we are accelerating, why can’t we feel it? Wouldn't we feel the reaction force? The acceleration can’t be that insignificant that we cannot feel it?

Help?
It's moving at 30/40 km/s I think. Not 100 000. Anyone who can confirm this?
 

Sanical

SpiderAnderson
Joined
Sep 7, 2011
Messages
499
Location
In the middle of Little Italy
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
Man I recommend you read "A Brief History Of Time" By Stephen Hawking. Very good book and explains a lot if you want to know more about that kind of stuff.
But this isn't about relativity or anything. I'm simply asking if we can feel the acceleration as we approach the sun. Well, I was bothered to figure it out and the reason we can't feel it is because the acceleration increases gradually, so it can't be felt. And it's also because we accelerate with the Earth as well
 

hayabusaboston

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 26, 2011
Messages
2,387
Location
Calabi Yau Manifold
Gender
Male
HSC
2013
So what was your problem again? That you don't understand how we can't feel the extra acceleration? In terms of our size on the Earth we need a MASSIVE acceleration before we become conscious of it, consider our speed without acceleration, approx 107,400km/h on average and relate that to the Astronomical Unit (149,598,000 km). The AU is 1400 times bigger. Now that is a HUGE difference, only an absolutely enormous acceleration would be felt by us, because of that difference, which is even small in the solar system, and our own size on Earth. Im not going to guess the acceleration required because I dont know, and everyone has different proprioceptive adaptations which allow them to feel different stimuli at different intensities, so it would be extremely difficult to extrapolate an accurate reading of "vestibular proprioception" for the general population.
I said km/h
 

romesh

Master of the Universe
Joined
Nov 10, 2004
Messages
26
Location
Sydney
Gender
Male
HSC
2006
Maybe they don't teach this clearly enough in HSC, but when it comes to 'feeling' force, you don't feel gravity. The reason, I suppose, is that you don't feel any force along a free-fall trajectory (neglecting friction). The reason you 'feel' weight on Earth is because you are *not* in free fall, you are being stopped by the ground. Thus it wouldn't matter if the gravitational force from the sun was 100x greater and you were falling straight into it, you wouldn't feel it unless something was acting against the resulting gravitational acceleration. Similarly, you don't feel any force in orbit because an orbit is a free-fall trajectory given your orbital velocity.

What you can feel though, is the gravitational gradient from a small, heavy source. That is, if you had a tiny, very massive object, the rate at which the gravitational force changed close to the object would be large. This could lead to a situation where say, your legs had a different gravitational force to your head, and you would definitely notice that.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top