• Best of luck to the class of 2024 for their HSC exams. You got this!
    Let us know your thoughts on the HSC exams here
  • YOU can help the next generation of students in the community!
    Share your trial papers and notes on our Notes & Resources page

Should we harvest the limbs of paraplegics (1 Viewer)

Graney

Horse liberty
Joined
Jul 17, 2007
Messages
4,434
Location
Bereie
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
Serious thread.


Whilst technology to repair spinal cords is still quite a way off, should we utilise the limbs of para/quadra-plegics to provide transplants to other people?
 

Omie Jay

gone
Joined
Nov 8, 2006
Messages
6,673
Location
in my own pants
Gender
Female
HSC
2007
with their consent, yes imo.

but who'd wanna look like a torso with a head, they'd probably wanna keep their arms and legs for aesthetic purposes, so i highly doubt this would ever happen.

not a bad idea though, it's not like they need their not-working-anymore arms and legs.
 

Graney

Horse liberty
Joined
Jul 17, 2007
Messages
4,434
Location
Bereie
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
plus they would be more efficient on their wheelchairs due to less dead weight
 

Graney

Horse liberty
Joined
Jul 17, 2007
Messages
4,434
Location
Bereie
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
what if there is no way for them to communicate
 

jb_nc

Google "9-11" and "truth"
Joined
Dec 20, 2004
Messages
5,391
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
what if there is no way for them to communicate
hmm thats a valid point

perhaps the legislation could stipulate that a lack of consent is equal to consent.

so an opt-out harvesting scheme
 

aussie-boy

Member
Joined
Nov 13, 2006
Messages
610
Gender
Male
HSC
2008
Wait a sec lol, how are they going to say upright in the bath? Or sit in a car seat? Or even in their wheelchairs lol?

How will people hug them, how will they wear clothes like the rest of us through which self expression can be achieved?

How will they use the bathroom, cushion themselves from a fall (even if involuntarily)?

etc etc
 
Joined
Apr 8, 2008
Messages
134
Location
In front of my computer screen...
Gender
Female
HSC
2009
No way! It's not right to give another living person's limbs away for whatever non life saving purpose. That's what prosthetic limbs are for. It's completely inhumane and makes people sound like spare parts factories rather than actual human beings. Besides, sometimes paraplegics recover, and in any case losing control of part of the body does not mean other parts become redundant.

This shouldn't even be a question, lol. :s *Holds on to own limbs just in case they get stolen*
 

madsam

God among men
Joined
Feb 16, 2008
Messages
250
Gender
Male
HSC
2009
What if, after the day after someone donates their limbs, they develop the technology to give them sensitivity back in their limbs? That'd suck then, cause tehre would be no hope

Also, who wants a cripples leg, have you seen them? They're basically just skin and bone anyway =\
 

Omie Jay

gone
Joined
Nov 8, 2006
Messages
6,673
Location
in my own pants
Gender
Female
HSC
2007
No way! It's not right to give another living person's limbs away for whatever non life saving purpose. That's what prosthetic limbs are for. It's completely inhumane and makes people sound like spare parts factories rather than actual human beings. Besides, sometimes paraplegics recover, and in any case losing control of part of the body does not mean other parts become redundant.

This shouldn't even be a question, lol. :s *Holds on to own limbs just in case they get stolen*
that's why "consent" is the keyword here.

as absurd as this sounds, it's not a bad idea, but like i said in my earlier post, i doubt many will consent to donating libs.
 

murphyad

Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2008
Messages
416
Location
Newy, brah!
Gender
Male
HSC
2009
Couple of things make me skeptical of this idea:

1. Whether or not there is the required level of demand for the legs, and

2. Given that it should hopefully be capable in the next 10 to 20 years to grow a limb from someone's DNA, it seems pointless to establish a large-scale operation for using the limbs of the handicapped.

Maybe as a short-term thing it might work, and with the proper regulation.
 

Serius

Beyond Godlike
Joined
Nov 10, 2004
Messages
3,123
Location
Wollongong
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
I think they usually like to keep them for balance, asthetics etc. Theres also breakthroughs with stem cell research, nanotech, robotics, happening all the time that you dont know when something could give you functionality again.

However, if they consented and wanted to donate their effectively useless limbs, i beleive they should be allowed to. I just dont see why they would want to.....also they should probably get a coupon for new limbs if a breakthrough did come along in the future that cured them. Also put them at the top of the list for experiments in regrowing limbs, reconnecting spinal cords etc.
 

SnowFox

Premium Member
Joined
Jan 27, 2009
Messages
5,455
Location
gone
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
2009
Wait a sec lol, how are they going to say upright in the bath? Or sit in a car seat? Or even in their wheelchairs lol?

How will people hug them, how will they wear clothes like the rest of us through which self expression can be achieved?

How will they use the bathroom, cushion themselves from a fall (even if involuntarily)?


etc etc
Last i checked Quadriplegics dont do many things.
 

Dombrovski

Member
Joined
Oct 3, 2007
Messages
120
Gender
Male
HSC
2008
I'd say yeah, sure, but its more of a matter of whether it could actually work...

If a limb has been out of action for a long time, the muscle atrophy would substanitally impare the benefit of that limb, and the resulting rehab would probably span for a very very long time

What about the significant immunological concerns? If surgery took place, and then the limb was rejected, that would be devasting to both parties; and then the amount of immunosuppressants needed would surely reduce the quality of life, even if the limb did "take" to the body.
You'd have to weigh out pros and cons there.

Also, wouldn't there be issues with bone marrow (depending on the age of the donor) as after all, it is an entire limb?
if the bones keep producing blood cells the immune response would be through the roof as the foreign cells would attempt to proliferate throughout the body, and the self response would destroy the cells. This then releases major toxins into the body, resulting in kidney and liver damage.

IF it could work, what if there was a limb donation service, working the same way as organ donation when you died?

Maybe not even a whole limb, maybe even just fingers and thumbs or something similar?
 

Graney

Horse liberty
Joined
Jul 17, 2007
Messages
4,434
Location
Bereie
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
No, without consent, because they are not utilising the limb properly
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top