• Want to help us with this year's BoS Trials?
    Let us know before 30 June. See this thread for details
  • Looking for HSC notes and resources?
    Check out our Notes & Resources page

Does God exist? (6 Viewers)

do you believe in god?


  • Total voters
    1,555

RANK 1

Active Member
Joined
Mar 16, 2011
Messages
1,369
Location
the hyperplane
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
I have not read what all of the previous 1074 pages have stated, but I skimmed through the first few, and though I would disprove one point that MoonLightSonata said...
• Why you cannot use a religious text to prove God’s existence

The claim here is that the religious text (Bible, Quran, etc) proves that God exists. This argument makes the fallacy of begging the question (or circular reasoning). When the argument is set out clearly this becomes obvious:

How do we know God exists?
God exists because the Bible says so.
Why should we believe the Bible?
Because the Bible is the word of God.
How do we know God exists?
God exists because the Bible says so.
Why should we believe the Bible?
Because the Bible is the word of God.

How do we know God exists?

(etc, ad infinitum.)

You cannot use the conclusion you are trying to prove (that God exists) as one of your premises. The premise “the Bible is the word of God” already assumes the truth of the conclusion.



Well, I can tell you that the bible is an actually a book containing the history of the world, many of the events that occurred were actually proved to have happened, this includes the floodings and such (are you going to try and prove that science does not work or exist either???). And it tells the fact that a man named Jesus was born to the earth and said that he was the son of God. All the people that described the miracles of Jesus could not have all made it up. Therefore if it were true, then God must exist as the Son of God existed.

My final point is that MoonLightSonata has chosen the weakest arguement they could find to try and prove their point. I believe that there is a God and his son Jesus came and died for us, but thats my beliefs, you are not obliged to believe in anything... BUT, just as I have faith that there is a God, many of you must have faith that your judgement is correct... but where is your proof that there is not God...

A story I would like to share with you is one on the link provided... http://www.columbia.edu/cu/ivcf/Sharing/Barber.htm
It is the story of a barber... it is not biblical just a nice short story...
Thanks
and im telling you that im the son of the jade emperor sent down from the heavens in spirit form and was born as a human, does that mean the jade emperor exists as well. people lie mate, also whilst scholars do generally agree that jesus did exist , they also agree that mary was not a virgin and had several children with joseph and jesus was not the eldest
 
Last edited:

MilkDrinker

Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2012
Messages
137
Gender
Female
HSC
2013
And how isn't the bible and God, "just a theory"?
The bible is not just a theory as i explained before, there are scientific discoveries that after examination of the earth (soil), that such occurances such as the flooding and such did actually occur...
 

RANK 1

Active Member
Joined
Mar 16, 2011
Messages
1,369
Location
the hyperplane
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
yeah, but the thing is other religions (which are also older) have stories of a great flooding or disaster as well which are attributed to their god/s. so why would christianity take precedence over those religions.
 

RANK 1

Active Member
Joined
Mar 16, 2011
Messages
1,369
Location
the hyperplane
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
yeah, but the thing is other religions (which are also older) have stories of a great flooding or disaster as well which are attributed to their god/s. so why would christianity take precedence over those religions.
heres a few

Africa

Southwest Tanzania
Once upon a time the rivers began to flood. The god told two people to get into a ship. He told them to take lots of seed and to take lots of animals. The water of the flood eventually covered the mountains. Finally the flood stopped. Then one of the men, wanting to know if the water had dried up let a dove loose. The dove returned. Later he let loose a hawk which did not return. Then the men left the boat and took the animals and the seeds with them.

Asia

China
The Chinese classic called the Hihking tells about "the family of Fuhi," that was saved from a great flood. This ancient story tells that the entire land was flooded; the mountains and everything, however one family survived in a boat. The Chinese consider this man the father of their civilization. This record indicates that Fuhi, his wife, three sons, and three daughters were the only people that escaped the great flood. It is claimed, that he and his family were the only people alive on earth, and repopulated the world.

Babylon
Gilgamesh met an old man named Utnapishtim, who told him the following story. The gods came to Utnapishtim to warn him about a terrible flood that was coming. They instructed Utnapishtim to destroy his house and build a large ship. The ship was to be 10 dozen cubits high, wide and long. Utnapishtim was to cover the ship with pitch. He was supposed to take male and female animals of all kinds, his wife and family, provisions, etc. into the ship. Once ship was completed the rain began falling intensely. The rain fell for six days and nights. Finally things calmed and the ship settled on the top of Mount Nisir. After the ship had rested for seven days Utnapishtim let loose a dove. Since the land had not dried the dove returned. Next he sent a swallow which also returned. Later he let loose a raven which never returned since the ground had dried. Utnapishtim then left the ship.

Chaldean
There was a man by the name of Xisuthrus. The god Chronos warned Xisuthrus of a coming flood and told him to build a boat. The boat was to be 5 stadia by 2 stadia. In this boat Xisuthrus was to put his family, friends and two of each animal (male and female). The flood came. When the waters started to recede he let some birds loose. They came back and he noticed they had mud on their feet. He tried again with the same results. When he tried the third time the birds did not return. Assuming the water had dried up the people got out of the boat and offered sacrifices to the gods.

India
A long time ago lived a man named Manu. Manu, while washing himself, saved a small fish from the jaws of a large fish. The fish told Manu, "If you care for me until I am full grown I will save you from terrible things to come". Manu asked what kind of terrible things. The fish told Manu that a great flood would soon come and destroy everything on the earth. The fish told Manu to put him in a clay jar for protection. The fish grew and each time he outgrew the clay jar Manu gave him a larger one. Finally the fish became a ghasha, one of the largest fish in the world. The fish instructed Manu to build a large ship since the flood was going to happen very soon. As the rains started Manu tied a rope from the ship to the ghasha. The fish guided the ship as the waters rose. The whole earth was covered by water. When the waters began subsiding the ghasha led Manu's ship to a mountaintop.

Australia

There is a legend of a flood called the Dreamtime flood. Riding on this flood was the woramba, or the Ark Gumana. In this ark was Noah, Aborigines, and various animals. This ark eventually came to rest in the plain of Djilinbadu where it can still be found. They claim that the white mans story about the ark landing in the middle east is a lie that was started to keep the aborigines in subservience. This legend is undoubtedly the product of aboriginal legends merging with those of visiting missionaries, and there does not appear to be any native flood stories from Australia.

Europe

Greece
A long time ago, perhaps before the golden age was over, humans became proud. This bothered Zeus as they kept getting worse. Finally Zeus decided that he would destroy all humans. Before he did this Prometheus, the creator of humans, warned his human son Deucalion and his wife Pyrrha. Prometheus then placed this couple in a large wooden chest. The rains started and lasted nine days and nights until the whole world was flooded. The only thing that was not flooded was the peaks of Mount Parnassus and Mount Olympus. Mount Olympus is the home of the gods. The wooden chest came to rest on Mount Parnassus. Deucalion and his wife Pyrrha got out and saw that everything was flooded. They lived on provisions from the chest until the waters subsided. At Zeus' instruction they re-populated the earth.

North America

Mexico
The Toltec natives have a legend telling that the original creation lasted for 1716 years, and was destroyed by a flood and only one family survived.

Aztec- A man named Tapi lived a long time ago. Tapi was a very pious man. The creator told Tapi to build a boat that he would live in. He was told that he should take his wife, a pair of every animal that was alive into this boat. Naturally everyone thought he was crazy. Then the rain started and the flood came. The men and animals tried to climb the mountains but the mountains became flooded as well. Finally the rain ended. Tapi decided that the water had dried up when he let a dove loose that did not return.

United States
The Ojibwe natives who have lived in Minnesota USA since approximately 1400AD also have a creation and flood story that closely parallels the Biblical account. "There came a time when the harmonious way of life did not continue. Men and women disrespected each other, families quarreled and soon villages began arguing back and forth. This saddened Gitchie Manido [the Creator] greatly, but he waited. Finally, when it seemed there was no hope left, Creator decided to purify Mother Earth through the use of water. The water came, flooding the Earth, catching all of creation off guard. All but a few of each living thing survived." Then it tells how Waynaboozhoo survived by floating on a log in the water with various animals.
Ojibwe - Ancient native American creation story tells of world wide flood.

Delaware Indians - In the pristine age, the world lived at peace; but an evil spirit came and caused a great flood. The earth was submerged. A few persons had taken refuge on the back of a turtle, so old that his shell had collected moss. A loon flew over their heads and was entreated to dive beneath the water and bring up land. It found only a bottomless sea. Then the bird flew far away, came back with a small portion of earth in its bill, and guided the tortoise to a place where there was a spot of dry land.

South America

Inca
During the period of time called the Pachachama people became very evil. They got so busy coming up with and performing evil deeds they neglected the gods. Only those in the high Andes remained uncorrupted. Two brothers who lived in the highlands noticed their llamas acting strangely. They asked the llamas why and were told that the stars had told the llamas that a great flood was coming. This flood would destroy all the life on earth. The brothers took their families and flocks into a cave on the high mountains. It started to rain and continued for four months. As the water rose the mountain grew keeping its top above the water. Eventually the rain stopped and the waters receded. The mountain returned to its original height. The shepherds repopulated the earth. The llamas remembered the flood and that is why they prefer to live in the highland areas.
 

funkshen

dvds didnt exist in 1991
Joined
Nov 5, 2006
Messages
2,137
Location
butt
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
I have not read what all of the previous 1074 pages have stated, but I skimmed through the first few, and though I would disprove one point that MilkDrinker said...
• Why you cannot use a comic book to prove Spiderman's existence

The claim here is that the comic book (The Amazing Spider-Man) proves that Spiderman exists. This argument makes the fallacy of begging the question (or circular reasoning). When the argument is set out clearly this becomes obvious:

How do we know Spiderman exists?
Spiderman exists because the comic book says so.
Why should we believe the comic book?
Because the comic book is the canon history of Spiderman.
How do we know Spiderman exists?
Spiderman exists because the comic book says so.
Why should we believe the comic book?
Because the comic book is the canon history of Spiderman.

How do we know Spiderman exists?

(etc, ad infinitum.)

You cannot use the conclusion you are trying to prove (that Spiderman exists) as one of your premises. The premise “the comic book is the official canon of Spiderman” already assumes the truth of the conclusion.


Well, I can tell you that the comic book is an actually a book containing the history of Spiderman and New York City, many of the events that occurred were actually proved to have happened, this includes fighting the green goblin and such (are you going to try and prove that science does not work or exist either? Explain Doctor Octopus). And it tells the fact that a man named Peter Parker was born to the earth, bitten by a radioactive spider, and said that he was Spiderman. All the people that described the superpowers of Spiderman could not have all made it up. Therefore if it were true, then Spiderman must exist as the amazing wall crawler.

My final point is that MilkDrinker has chosen the weakest arguement they could find to try and prove his point. I believe that there is a Peter Parker, and he as Spiderman came and protected New York City, but thats my beliefs, you are not obliged to believe in anything... BUT, just as I have faith that there is a Spiderman, many of you must have faith that your judgement is correct... but where is your proof that there is not Spiderman...

A story I would like to share with you is one on the link provided... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4o29VoxtsFk
It is the story of a Spiderman... it is not comical, just a nice short song.
Thanks
 

MilkDrinker

Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2012
Messages
137
Gender
Female
HSC
2013
I will not go into which religion is the true one but would just like to say that with my resources and knowledge, there is proof that there is a God, whether u guys accept it or not is ur problem... but this was set up to see whether god exists
 

zombies

Member
Joined
Aug 8, 2011
Messages
663
Location
Riften
Gender
Female
HSC
2013
I will not go into which religion is the true one but would just like to say that with my resources and knowledge, there is proof that there is a God, whether u guys accept it or not is ur problem... but this was set up to see whether god exists
But there isn't.
 

barbernator

Active Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
1,439
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
GOD EXISTS IN MY HEART 4 LYF <3 <3 <3 PROVE HE DOESN'T EXIST BITCHEZZZZZ
 

RANK 1

Active Member
Joined
Mar 16, 2011
Messages
1,369
Location
the hyperplane
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
I will not go into which religion is the true one but would just like to say that with my resources and knowledge, there is proof that there is a God, whether u guys accept it or not is ur problem... but this was set up to see whether god exists
your resources and knowledge are clearly very limited and what is this proof you speak of?
(faith does not count as proof)
 

MilkDrinker

Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2012
Messages
137
Gender
Female
HSC
2013
I have not read what all of the previous 1074 pages have stated, but I skimmed through the first few, and though I would disprove one point that MilkDrinker said...
• Why you cannot use a comic book to prove Spiderman's existence

The claim here is that the comic book (The Amazing Spider-Man) proves that Spiderman exists. This argument makes the fallacy of begging the question (or circular reasoning). When the argument is set out clearly this becomes obvious:

How do we know Spiderman exists?
Spiderman exists because the comic book says so.
Why should we believe the comic book?
Because the comic book is the canon history of Spiderman.
How do we know Spiderman exists?
Spiderman exists because the comic book says so.
Why should we believe the comic book?
Because the comic book is the canon history of Spiderman.

How do we know Spiderman exists?

(etc, ad infinitum.)

You cannot use the conclusion you are trying to prove (that Spiderman exists) as one of your premises. The premise “the comic book is the official canon of Spiderman” already assumes the truth of the conclusion.


Well, I can tell you that the comic book is an actually a book containing the history of Spiderman and New York City, many of the events that occurred were actually proved to have happened, this includes fighting the green goblin and such (are you going to try and prove that science does not work or exist either? Explain Doctor Octopus). And it tells the fact that a man named Peter Parker was born to the earth, bitten by a radioactive spider, and said that he was Spiderman. All the people that described the superpowers of Spiderman could not have all made it up. Therefore if it were true, then Spiderman must exist as the amazing wall crawler.

My final point is that MilkDrinker has chosen the weakest arguement they could find to try and prove his point. I believe that there is a Peter Parker, and he as Spiderman came and protected New York City, but thats my beliefs, you are not obliged to believe in anything... BUT, just as I have faith that there is a Spiderman, many of you must have faith that your judgement is correct... but where is your proof that there is not Spiderman...

A story I would like to share with you is one on the link provided... http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4o29VoxtsFk
It is the story of a Spiderman... it is not comical, just a nice short song.
Thanks
since u are going to try and play this game with me, prove to me using historical documents, or documents on any kind to prove that a man named peter parker existed and had been bitten by a radioactive spider... i am not asking for fictional proof but real documentation
 

MilkDrinker

Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2012
Messages
137
Gender
Female
HSC
2013
clearly u have not heard of any of the miracles that have occured. there is even video documentation of it...
 

cheezcake

Callipygian Member
Joined
Mar 14, 2010
Messages
596
Location
Gliese 581 d
Gender
Male
HSC
2011
since u are going to try and play this game with me, prove to me using historical documents, or documents on any kind to prove that a man named peter parker existed and had been bitten by a radioactive spider... i am not asking for fictional proof but real documentation
Hahaha, seriously do you not see the fallacy in this
 

MilkDrinker

Member
Joined
Jan 26, 2012
Messages
137
Gender
Female
HSC
2013
well i am not going to argue with u any longer, this does not mean i give up, it just means that you are a bunch of stubborn people. when the day of judgement comes, u cannot deny that u were not informed... good luck with ur lives....
 

barbernator

Active Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2010
Messages
1,439
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
well i am not going to argue with u any longer, this does not mean i give up, it just means that you are a bunch of stubborn people. when the day of judgement comes, u cannot deny that u were not informed... good luck with ur lives....
kudos, rot in hell unfaithful people
 

zeebobDD

Member
Joined
Oct 23, 2011
Messages
414
Gender
Male
HSC
2012
look at some of these long as paragraphs n thinking fk no way im bothered to read this
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 6)

Top