Donne (1 Viewer)

Divya

New Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2002
Messages
4
Location
Epping
Gender
Female
HSC
2001
donne- criticism

I didnt like any of the religious poetry- but the love poetry (i.e. valediction) was realli good.
Our skool had studied criticism from:
- Stevie Davies (feminist- Sunne Rising),
- Helen Gardner (Batter- psycho),
- Elaine Hobby (feminist +psychoanalytical - Sunne Rising, psycho-Valediction) and
- Stanley Fish (he jus raved on abt donne being a looser)

they were all pretty good.
I understand the problem with how the criticisms of Donne's poetry are harder to understand that the poetry itself (and we actualli went thru a criticism which I remember "criticised" the criticisms of being too "technical").
 

smegger_em

Clever Cookie
Joined
Jul 7, 2002
Messages
404
Location
Melbourne, or as it shoulda, could, woulda been ca
Gender
Female
HSC
2002
Thanks for all that, i just find critical material to be a little over-whelming at times. I just sometimes wonder about all the people who find homo-erotic or marxist or exestentionalist or post-modern refernces in EVERY single poem from nursery ryhmes to limricks to epic ballards..
 

Jacinta

New Member
Joined
Jul 8, 2002
Messages
10
Location
Wagga Wagga
Em if u do find anything useful i would love for u to show me!!! (that's about as subtle as i get) I have just some of the stuff from my class and i haven't gotten anything really outstanding or interesting. It's actually all a bit pointless and boring.
 

tweakin

Member
Joined
Jul 10, 2002
Messages
112
my playes last scene

Donne suxxxx.
Anyone got any info on the holy sonnet "my playes last scene"?
THanks
 

pulse

New Member
Joined
Jul 7, 2002
Messages
22
Location
Dark Side of the Moon
meh meh meh meh

emily quilty and mac have, i would think, about 400 pages of photocopied stuff from critics and donne. why dont you just borrow form their private stash.....they will lend it to you
 

smegger_em

Clever Cookie
Joined
Jul 7, 2002
Messages
404
Location
Melbourne, or as it shoulda, could, woulda been ca
Gender
Female
HSC
2002
Becuase they didnt bother referncing it!!
You know when we were given some in class and had to go through it, they put the publisher and everything on it but for got the AUTHOR. They are stupider then me and its very frustrating
And also cause i am lazy and wanted people to help me so it took less time
 

Minai

Alumni
Joined
Jul 7, 2002
Messages
7,458
Location
Sydney
Gender
Male
HSC
2002
Uni Grad
2006
they are pretty intelligent when u think about it
but way too influenced by his context and personal views and religion

but hey, thats the point rite....
 

ice_cream

Member
Joined
Jul 21, 2002
Messages
65
how can you like donne's poems!!??
how many critics are we expected to know? cos have limited information on critics..and that 400pg stuff that some1 mentioned..i don't think i even have 10% of it....
 

Big Willy

Cabra Junkie RULES
Joined
Jul 18, 2002
Messages
407
Location
Killarney Hts
Gender
Male
HSC
2002
I got plenty of crap on Donne, but they are all notes and photcopies from the teacher

I think you should relax with the critics (ie dont get stressed by them). From what i understand, you just need a stance from each critic, and the historical context from which they are from. (correct me if i'm wrong).

The aim of this module is 'critical study of text', and hence, you should focus on how his ideas are praised/criticsed by urself and other criticts (3 is enough). Dont mix 'ideas' with textual integrity (eg techniques, devices and shit like that)
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top