Favourite band(s) (2 Viewers)

[wanton-wonton]

met-motherfucking-tallica

 

[Phanatical]

why is there a difference between composers and songwriters? its all about the invention of melody isnt it?

I am highly insulted by this. As a composer, I resent being compared to some shit songwriter. Composers work with harmonies, instrumentation, rhythms and many other facets of music creation. Songwriters are like a bastardised version of composers, in that they only work in one Tiny area of composition.

 

[SitDownStandUp]

I am highly insulted by this. As a composer, I resent being compared to some shit songwriter. Composers work with harmonies, instrumentation, rhythms and many other facets of music creation. Songwriters are like a bastardised version of composers, in that they only work in one Tiny area of composition.

Surely your favourite band's songwriter isn't 'shit'?.

 

[artfag]

 

[dave_119]

I am highly insulted by this. As a composer, I resent being compared to some shit songwriter. Composers work with harmonies, instrumentation, rhythms and many other facets of music creation. Songwriters are like a bastardised version of composers, in that they only work in one Tiny area of composition.

i dont giv a shit about what u think.... ur a composer, LOSER!!!! you argue on everything, u sack of crap... i think mozart was religious, he wouldn't want christianity banned.. im sure bach was christian...
U SUCK

 

[saves.the.day]

i dont giv a shit about what u think.... ur a composer, LOSER!!!! you argue on everything, u sack of crap... i think mozart was religious, he wouldn't want christianity banned.. im sure bach was christian...
U SUCK

Hi, I just got really curious so I have to ask: what does bach and mozart being religious or christian have anything to do with Phanatical being a composer?

 

[chelloveck]

what is the point int that? i mean, why did you do it?

 

[artfag]

because Love are the best band?

 

[chelloveck]

so say it.

 

[artfag]

that time of the month again?

 

[breaking]

jejejejejejje

 

[neo o]

Artfag, I've always wondered this - is you're avatar a malformed penis? Or a guy tied up.. or what? I haven't quite been able to figure it out.

 

[artfag]

http://www.babyart.org/japabon05.htm

 

[breaking]

charming..

 

[chelloveck]

that time of the month again?

no i just hate you.

 

[mcdickpants 2.5]

I am highly insulted by this. As a composer, I resent being compared to some shit songwriter. Composers work with harmonies, instrumentation, rhythms and many other facets of music creation. Songwriters are like a bastardised version of composers, in that they only work in one Tiny area of composition.

that is the most increadibly arrogant thing i have read in a long time. just because classical composers have more prestige surrounding them, doesnt mean that the work of pop/rock writers is any less valid. Your arguments are all moot anyway because ALL songwriters have to deal with "harmonies, instrumentation, rhythms and many other facets of music creation.", its only that better writers are more adept at utilising them. and besides, all forms of composition have rules to follow, so i don't see how you can differentiate between writing for classical music (which has more complex rules like counterpoint for instance) and pop music.

the end

 

[mcdickpants 2.5]

no i just hate you.

well if both of you were on fire, i know who i'd extinguish....


come to think of it, id probably be thirsty, so i'd drink the water myself.

 

[mcdickpants 2.5]

pps arthur lee's love rock out

 

[bluesky100]

Best band in the world? .............

# REM
@ Midnight Oil
^ U2
* Meat Loaf
& The Living End

 

[taxman]

Woah...with the legion of Radiohead fans on this board, I would have expected at least one vote for them. In my opinion, the best bands (as it is way too difficult to award a clear-cut winner) are:

- TISM
- Avril Lavigne
- Frenzal Rhomb
- Anal Cunt
- Group X
- Devo
- Counting Crows