Galvanic Cell Help! (1 Viewer)

Abtari

Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2004
Messages
604
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
hi there,

just one question i am confused about...

in a Zn|Zn++ and Cu|Cu++ galvanic cell, because Zn is more electropositive than copper, it gets oxidised and thus there is electron flow from the zinc terminal (anode) to copper terminal (cathode) right? Is the CURRENT flow the same, i.e. from zinc anode to copper cathode?

If you set up this experiment and attach an ammeter, you will find that the ammeter has a positive reading with zinc/anode/negative terminal as the +ve terminal and copper/cathode/positive terminal as the -ve terminal. This means that current does flow from zinc to copper.

But, how can both current and electrons flow in the same direction... HELP.

Thanks heaps.
 

physician

Some things never change.
Joined
Oct 21, 2004
Messages
1,432
Location
Bankstown bro
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
Abtari said:
hi there,

just one question i am confused about...

in a Zn|Zn++ and Cu|Cu++ galvanic cell, because Zn is more electropositive than copper, it gets oxidised and thus there is electron flow from the zinc terminal (anode) to copper terminal (cathode) right? Is the CURRENT flow the same, i.e. from zinc anode to copper cathode?

If you set up this experiment and attach an ammeter, you will find that the ammeter has a positive reading with zinc/anode/negative terminal as the +ve terminal and copper/cathode/positive terminal as the -ve terminal. This means that current does flow from zinc to copper.

But, how can both current and electrons flow in the same direction... HELP.

Thanks heaps.

Doesn't that mean the current flows from copper to zinc since copper now becames the anode... and zinc becomes the cathode It'll be from copper anode to zinc cathode... which is in the oppsoite direction to electron flow...

are we supposed to know about the current flow in a galvanic cell?...
 

Will Hunting

Member
Joined
Oct 22, 2004
Messages
214
Location
Carlton
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
Hey Abtari,

Everything you have stated is correct, but you seem to be working on a wrong assumption. The ammeter measures "electron current", which "does" flow in the same direction as electrons. I'm guessing you've assumed current to be "conventional" for the purpose of this exercise, which moves in the opposite direction to electrons (Conventional current is defined as a flow of positive charge). It must be noted, however, that conventional current has no physical reality (since electrons are all that are mobile in a circuit). It is only a principle designed to explain the equivalence of moving electrons and positive charge which, although doesn't move, can be treated as doing so because of the mobility of the electrons. An ammeter is a device that measures only what is real (i.e. electron current).
 

physician

Some things never change.
Joined
Oct 21, 2004
Messages
1,432
Location
Bankstown bro
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
Will Hunting said:
Hey Abtari,

Everything you have stated is correct, but you seem to be working on a wrong assumption. The ammeter measures "electron current", which "does" flow in the same direction as electrons. I'm guessing you've assumed current to be "conventional" for the purpose of this exercise, which moves in the opposite direction to electrons (Conventional current is defined as a flow of positive charge). It must be noted, however, that conventional current has no physical reality (since electrons are all that are mobile in a circuit). It is only a principle designed to explain the equivalence of moving electrons and positive charge which, although doesn't move, can be treated as doing so because of the mobility of the electrons. An ammeter is a device that measures only what is real (i.e. electron current).
thanks dude... although this was directed towards Abtari but u cleared that up for me too... sorry Abtari if u read my post and went wacko...
 

Will Hunting

Member
Joined
Oct 22, 2004
Messages
214
Location
Carlton
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
That's cool, man. I know how tricky it can be sometimes to get these things the right way around! What your said actually makes sense in Physics, when you start talking about things like cathodes and anodes in photocells, CRTs and CROs. The most important thing to remember about galvanic cells is that "oxidation occurs at the anode and reduction occurs at the cathode". Also note that this won't change whatever cyou define current as. Hence, the electron flow direction should be thought of more in terms of this property than in terms of polarity.
 

Abtari

Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2004
Messages
604
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
galvanic cell question

Thanks for your input guys but still a bit hazy. Let's clear it up.

just one question:
if you set up the galvanic cell as i have mentioned above with Zn as anode and Cu as cathode, then will a galvaometer placed in series deflect towards the right (direction of flow of electron current) or left (direction of flow of conventional current). My opinion is that the galvanometer should deflect left since it detects conventional current not "electron" current.

Which direction do you think?
 

Sirius Black

Maths is beautiful
Joined
Mar 18, 2004
Messages
286
Location
some where down the south
Gender
Female
HSC
2005
To the right.
Zinc anode is the e- provider so its supposed to be -ve; whereas Cu cathode is +ve as it accepts e-s. The actual eletron flows from anode to cathode and once u connect +ve terminal to anode (which is -ve) and -ve terminal to cathode (which is +ve), the e-s flow from +ve terminal to -ve terminal therefore it results in +ve deflection i.e. to the right
Hoho hope it helps(p.s. I think you'd better forget about the so-called conventional current, coz in fact, current is defined as the movement of electrons. you only need to take serious consideration about electrons and conventional current in phys if you are doing M&G)
 

Abtari

Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2004
Messages
604
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
Sirius Black said:
To the right.
The actual eletron flows from anode to cathode and once u connect +ve terminal to anode (which is -ve) and -ve terminal to cathode (which is +ve), the e-s flow from +ve terminal to -ve terminal therefore it results in +ve deflection i.e. to the right
when you say connect +ve terminal to anode, are you talking about the terminal of a galvanometer or what? this is not clear...
 

Sirius Black

Maths is beautiful
Joined
Mar 18, 2004
Messages
286
Location
some where down the south
Gender
Female
HSC
2005
sorrie for my unclear statement above. The terminals i mentioned above did refer to teh galvanometer :p

btw, here is another q- did u use ammeter or voltmeter in the expt - does it matter which one u used(I know Voltmeter could tell u the Ecell,but what if i only want to know wether my cell couples will conduct electrivity or not)?
 

jarro_2783

Member
Joined
Dec 1, 2004
Messages
63
Location
Australia
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
if you want to know whether it conducts then I suppose either will work because a voltmeter will tell you the voltage across the cell, and an ammeter will tell you how much current is flowing.
Depending on the type of voltmeter you use, some can't be negative because the needle only has a positive reading. So if it doesn't read try switching the terminals.
 

:daryl

New Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2005
Messages
2
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
ummmm. yus dat hav domne da 1st assesment at school, is it da battery one? im doin it at tafe n wer behind n always catching up to yus who go to school. nyways has anyone done da battaery assesment, if so can u help me out wid resources? thanx
 

Pace_T

Active Member
Joined
Oct 21, 2004
Messages
1,784
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
:daryl said:
ummmm. yus dat hav domne da 1st assesment at school, is it da battery one? im doin it at tafe n wer behind n always catching up to yus who go to school. nyways has anyone done da battaery assesment, if so can u help me out wid resources? thanx

sure thing mate,
im pretty sure this is in the syllabus, under the electrochemistry topic.
if you look in the resource section on the main page you can find numerous notes on the core topic (production of materials) and under the electrochemistry section of peoples notes there will be a major dot point in which students have to assess 2 batteries from a selection of about 5-6 or somewhere near there
the assessment includes practicality, economic, chemistry (chemistry behind it) and one more i think (i dont know if you have the same assignment??)
the numerous notes should provide all the info you need.

hope i helped :)
 

taxman

make poverty
Joined
Sep 13, 2004
Messages
413
Location
Inside Your Head
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
Pace_T said:
sure thing mate,
im pretty sure this is in the syllabus, under the electrochemistry topic.
if you look in the resource section on the main page you can find numerous notes on the core topic (production of materials) and under the electrochemistry section of peoples notes there will be a major dot point in which students have to assess 2 batteries from a selection of about 5-6 or somewhere near there
the assessment includes practicality, economic, chemistry (chemistry behind it) and one more i think (i dont know if you have the same assignment??)
the numerous notes should provide all the info you need.

hope i helped :)
Goddamn Pace...so lazy, referring people to the notes section :p
 

Rax

Custom Me up Scotty
Joined
Jul 30, 2005
Messages
229
Location
In the Bush
Gender
Male
HSC
2006
Um eh what is a galvanometer..... (tell me its a volt or ammeter)
but seriously I dont remeber any reference to galvanometer in my text book or syllabus
thanks in advance
 

rama_v

Active Member
Joined
Oct 22, 2004
Messages
1,151
Location
Western Sydney
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
Rax said:
Um eh what is a galvanometer..... (tell me its a volt or ammeter)
but seriously I dont remeber any reference to galvanometer in my text book or syllabus
thanks in advance
a galvanometer is just a device that measures current flow. Its basically an ammeter except it can usually measure much smaller current flows (i.e. in milli or microamps)
 

Riviet

.
Joined
Oct 11, 2005
Messages
5,593
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
A terminal is where you insert the wire to connect the galvanometer to the half cells.
 

insert-username

Wandering the Lacuna
Joined
Jun 6, 2005
Messages
1,226
Location
NSW
Gender
Male
HSC
2006
Galvanometers aren't mentioned in the syllabus as I remember. Terminals are connected to the electrodes.


I_F
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top