John The Great
Banned
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2005
- Messages
- 45
- Gender
- Male
- HSC
- 2006
It really is unbelievable that so many people wish to comment on issues that they have no reliable or accurate conception of. Unfortunately in contemporary society, with the idea of rights, everybody believes they can comment on and in particular criticise peoples and events without any formal knowledge in the area. This thread has been an example.
Every comment here has been terrible, with no formal knowledge of the nazi ideology that they so vehemently criticise, or of the individual being Hitler. The only comment that is even slightly credible is Ryken's comment with his mention of Mein Kampf. Being perhaps the only person here, with the possible exception of Ryken, to have read Mein Kampf, it is appalling to read these comments saying the Nazis had no justification for their acts. That these acts were only formed at the time, with no planning, or formal ideology behind them. The Nazi ideology as formulated by Hitler, was an incredible ideology, its rapid success is evidence of this. For those of you who have criticised Hitler's genius, or his ability to understand politics and social predicaments, perhaps you should read Mein Kampf. This man knew exactly how politics worked, and understood the people, and most importantly, the German people. He undertsood the failings of social democracy, of parliment, and of the Bourgeoisie's social relationships. So his intelligence cant be criticised, he was without doubt a genius under our current definition.
Some limited individuals have also said his work makes no sense. Perhaps it is their intelligence, or lack there of, that makes them incapable of making sense of his work. His work makes sense, just as all other great works have. The ridiculous defamation of him and his work is entirely unjustified and merely media taboo. The only source of misunderstanding of his work comes from translation. By the way, to he who wrote Hitler was deffinately "fucked in the head", what led you to this conclusion? For if Hitler is to be considered fucked in the head, then so are all great men, such as Socrates, Aristotle, Alexander, Caesar, Jesus, Napoleon and so on.
Then people say that Hitler was evil. That Hitler was wrong. That the holocaust was wrong. Well, all these comments do, is make it unambiguous to the educated that you have never read any philosophy, or theology. For one can not say that Hitler was wrong, in fact Hitler was good according to Aristotle's ethics. Nietzsche certainly would have viewed him highly, with his overman like ability, and his diregarding of slave mentality, which you who have commented here all suffer under. The Final Solution, was necessary for the survival and prosperity of Germany. That involved not just the Aryan race, but the christian religion. Now as all of you who have read St. Augustine's works City of God, or Confessions would know, violence transcends ethics when required to defend ones faith. Thus, one can not say that Hitler was bad as he ordered the defence of Germany, and its culture.
So before criticising this great individual any longer without justification, you should learn the area better and forget the slave mentality of the contemporary media with its taboo. As Hitler wrote, "sucess is the sole earthly judge of right and wrong", and Hitler was certainly successful, or perhaps as Virgil wrote, "fortune favours the bold".
Every comment here has been terrible, with no formal knowledge of the nazi ideology that they so vehemently criticise, or of the individual being Hitler. The only comment that is even slightly credible is Ryken's comment with his mention of Mein Kampf. Being perhaps the only person here, with the possible exception of Ryken, to have read Mein Kampf, it is appalling to read these comments saying the Nazis had no justification for their acts. That these acts were only formed at the time, with no planning, or formal ideology behind them. The Nazi ideology as formulated by Hitler, was an incredible ideology, its rapid success is evidence of this. For those of you who have criticised Hitler's genius, or his ability to understand politics and social predicaments, perhaps you should read Mein Kampf. This man knew exactly how politics worked, and understood the people, and most importantly, the German people. He undertsood the failings of social democracy, of parliment, and of the Bourgeoisie's social relationships. So his intelligence cant be criticised, he was without doubt a genius under our current definition.
Some limited individuals have also said his work makes no sense. Perhaps it is their intelligence, or lack there of, that makes them incapable of making sense of his work. His work makes sense, just as all other great works have. The ridiculous defamation of him and his work is entirely unjustified and merely media taboo. The only source of misunderstanding of his work comes from translation. By the way, to he who wrote Hitler was deffinately "fucked in the head", what led you to this conclusion? For if Hitler is to be considered fucked in the head, then so are all great men, such as Socrates, Aristotle, Alexander, Caesar, Jesus, Napoleon and so on.
Then people say that Hitler was evil. That Hitler was wrong. That the holocaust was wrong. Well, all these comments do, is make it unambiguous to the educated that you have never read any philosophy, or theology. For one can not say that Hitler was wrong, in fact Hitler was good according to Aristotle's ethics. Nietzsche certainly would have viewed him highly, with his overman like ability, and his diregarding of slave mentality, which you who have commented here all suffer under. The Final Solution, was necessary for the survival and prosperity of Germany. That involved not just the Aryan race, but the christian religion. Now as all of you who have read St. Augustine's works City of God, or Confessions would know, violence transcends ethics when required to defend ones faith. Thus, one can not say that Hitler was bad as he ordered the defence of Germany, and its culture.
So before criticising this great individual any longer without justification, you should learn the area better and forget the slave mentality of the contemporary media with its taboo. As Hitler wrote, "sucess is the sole earthly judge of right and wrong", and Hitler was certainly successful, or perhaps as Virgil wrote, "fortune favours the bold".