Kelly/Ruben/Fantasia - The Best American Idol (1 Viewer)

[Survivor39]

You heard them sing. It's your vote!

1. Kelly - Buying all her albums/singles
2. Fantasia - meh...
3. Ruben - meh...meh...too sweaty....

 

[Fry]

personally, i love Kelly Clarkson the best. her voice is just beaut.

Ruben's voice isnt too bad either. i heard him sing for the first time tonight. when you look away, you can't really tell its a fat guy singing.

 

[jm1234567890]

too sweaty, lol

 

[MouNtY]

....kelly clarkson is by far the better singer of the three......

Originally posted by Fry
Ruben's voice isnt too bad either. i heard him sing for the first time tonight. when you look away, you can't really tell its a fat guy singing.

.........i didn't know it was possible to distinguish a fat persons singing voice from that of a skinny person.........but i think you can always tell whether they're black or white though.....

 

[Fry]

well when i looked away, i pictured this skinny, tall, handsome dude singing. he sounded a bit like Usher..

 

[jm1234567890]

Originally posted by DooNy_TeChY
.........i didn't know it was possible to distinguish a fat persons singing voice from that of a skinny person.........but i think you can always tell whether they're black or white though.....

What about michael jackson

 

[Suney_J]

Originally posted by Fry
when you look away, you can't really tell its a fat guy singing.

how bout clay aiken?, he's worse than ruben when it come to voice matching

 

[hatty]

yes Kelly Clarkson is really good, i rate her as the best American idol.
and she's hot..

i reckon Clay is better then Ruben, he shoulda won...

Fantasia is good, she comes 2nd

 

[MouNtY]

Originally posted by hatty
yes Kelly Clarkson is really good, i rate her as the best American idol.
and she's hot..

i reckon Clay is better then Ruben, he shoulda won...

Fantasia is good, she comes 2nd

AGREE with you on all counts..........dayum she'sHOTT........Clay should've won........and Fantasia is good but diana should've won........coz she's HOTT too..........

 

[Fry]

Diana hot?? you gotta get your eyes checked.

 

[glycerine]

kelly clarkson shouts too much

i find it really disturbing that you're all so concerned with their looks/bodies, if there's one thing idol's proved, you don't have to be stick thin and gorgeous to be admired, just look at world idol

 

[MouNtY]

Originally posted by Fry
Diana hot?? you gotta get your eyes checked.

WTF! ! ! Diana is friggin HOTT

 

[jm1234567890]

Originally posted by glycerine
kelly clarkson shouts too much

i find it really disturbing that you're all so concerned with their looks/bodies, if there's one thing idol's proved, you don't have to be stick thin and gorgeous to be admired, just look at world idol

He only won because of the LOTR craze and the hobbit comment

 

[MouNtY]

Originally posted by jm1234567890
He only won because of the LOTR craze and the hobbit comment

.....I AGREE 100%...........

 

[hatty]

dianna is DISGUSTING

kelly... now theres a work of art..

 

[MouNtY]

Originally posted by jm1234567890
What about michael jackson

.........That's true that guy sings totally white.......as in the sound of his voice i mean...........before anyone goes and uppity about it........

 

[hatty]

Originally posted by glycerine
kelly clarkson shouts too much

i find it really disturbing that you're all so concerned with their looks/bodies, if there's one thing idol's proved, you don't have to be stick thin and gorgeous to be admired, just look at world idol

i hate that norwegian bastard

cant sing... for shit
but that would be excusable if he was good looking (eg. kylie minogue.)
but is he?
HELL NO
sympathy winner they call it.

 

[Survivor39]

Originally posted by glycerine
kelly clarkson shouts too much

meh, didn't you hear her performance tonight?

Beautiful disaster......

 

[glycerine]

Originally posted by jm1234567890
He only won because of the LOTR craze and the hobbit comment

well i genuinely thought he was good, and btw, i wasn't even looking at the tv when he came on, i only heard him. PS. i highly doubt lotr is a 'craze' in saudi arabia : )

Originally posted by Survivor39
meh, didn't you hear her performance tonight?

Beautiful disaster......

i did...the combined one? and she was better than usual, i just dont think shes the best. i haven't heard enough of ruben to judge though.

 

[Trigger189]

fucking eww, diana hot? leah labelle, she was hot! YIKES MAN!

kelly does shout too much, but she is good, and best of the winners. Fantasia sounds like a dying cat when she goes for the high notes