Kelly/Ruben/Fantasia - The Best American Idol (1 Viewer)

[iambored]

OK:

what about when guy sebastian was on rove
rove asked him what kelly was like
guy didn't really comment. if she was nice, he would have said something along the lines of that she's a great girl and the rumors were wrong
but he said almost nothing, besides, uh yeah and gave some sort of look

edit: i got the deets wrong but the general meaning was right. documented here:
http://www.boredofstudies.org/commu...ostid=524161&highlight=guy+on+rove#post524161

 

[Survivor39]

Originally posted by iambored

what about when guy sebastian was on rove
rove asked him what kelly was like
guy didn't really comment. if she was nice, he would have said something along the lines of that she's a great girl and the rumors were wrong
but he said almost nothing, besides, uh yeah and gave some sort of look
[/url]

pfft...since when did he said anything good about anybody....

 

[Annegelic]

Originally posted by jm1234567890
He only won because of the LOTR craze and the hobbit comment

bah.. world idol was rorted. it was a popularity contest, nothing about talent. Guy kicks Kelly, Fantasia, Ruben & Diana's ass ! =P

 

[MicK_eT]

i think kelly was expecting to win that too... personally i was hoping guy would chart higher than he did... cuz he was representing us!~ but meh... anyway.. i think that jasmine was hot... clay aiken isnt that great... ruben isnt physically appealing but he has a good voice.. kelly has a good voice too.. fantasia is ok but shes more entertainment in the fact that shes better to watch cuz she moves around and interacts than just standing there... but yea... still her voice is not that great