Originally posted by jm1234567890
minidisc is useless!!
Reasons:
1. they are fatter than mp3 players
2. they store less stuff compared to mp3 players
3. their batteries don't last as long as mp3 players
4. they are more expensive compared to mp3 players
a solid state mp3 player is much better than any minidisc player.
and if you have lots of money to spend get an ipod
I'd have to disagree with you
1) Yes, but not that fat
2) 4CD's isn't sufficient? I think it should suffice for now
3) Yeah umm right... some mp3 players require AAA, and they cost heaps, and some have inbuilt batteries, which is gay as well, the MD's battery life is 10 times as better than a mp3 player no joke
4) Yeah i guess so, but there discs are cheap, think about it 5 Bucks for a 74 min, which can store 4 cds, and they do look rather stylish. And you got your typical 64 MB Inbuilt memory for your mp3 player at about 300 For an alright one, then you want to fit more songs, ok here comes the memory card, another 64 mb would cost you around 90 - 120, depending what mp3 player it is, and it all accumulates, while if you get the NET MD, for roughly around 530 Bucks, you got yourself a good looking system, and the media is cheaper than purchasing memory.
I'd also like to add a point is, can a mp3 player, to recordings using a mic like MD's can? Did you also realise, your limited in Bitrate quality for mp3 players, to upload to, while the MD has a variety.
Oh well just my 2 cents.