• Best of luck to the class of 2024 for their HSC exams. You got this!
    Let us know your thoughts on the HSC exams here
  • YOU can help the next generation of students in the community!
    Share your trial papers and notes on our Notes & Resources page
MedVision ad

Does God exist? (9 Viewers)

do you believe in god?


  • Total voters
    1,568

boris

Banned
Joined
May 6, 2004
Messages
4,671
Gender
Male
HSC
2007
Is it a commonly held belief that atheists lack morals/values? And that because we don't follow the Bible or don't believe in God, it's impossible for us to be model citizens?

That's the impression I get from these online Bible bashers.
 

Kwayera

Passive-aggressive Mod
Joined
May 10, 2004
Messages
5,959
Location
Antarctica
Gender
Female
HSC
2005
Yes. Because we are not Biblical believers, we are incapable of holding any genuinely "moral" viewpoint, because apparently all morals originate in religious belief in a God. Or something.
 
Joined
Dec 10, 2006
Messages
725
Gender
Male
HSC
2008
Pretty funny that amongst the atheists on this forum we have many vegetarians/animal lovers... IMHO a 'higher' (not to say better before anyone jumps on me) form of morality than your everyday person exhibits.


higher: Because it requires further extensions of basic empathy to care for different species than it does just other humans.
 

Slidey

But pieces of what?
Joined
Jun 12, 2004
Messages
6,600
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
KFunk said:
Haha, I'm an atheist and an ethical relativist and I still don't eat meat as a result of the ethical views I hold (despite acknowledging that they are just subjective preferences).
Likewise.

I'm sick of zealots claiming I lack moral character because I do not believe in a higher being. Perhaps they should look up the real meaning of the word hedonism, too:

"Hedonism is the philosophy that pleasure is the most important pursuit."

Typically any person, atheist or not, is fairly hedonistic. Personally I follow utilitarian hedonism: we should perform the actions which maximise pleasure and minimise pain for everyone.
 

boris

Banned
Joined
May 6, 2004
Messages
4,671
Gender
Male
HSC
2007
Kwayera said:
Yes. Because we are not Biblical believers, we are incapable of holding any genuinely "moral" viewpoint, because apparently all morals originate in religious belief in a God. Or something.
It's because we believe in dinosaurs, isnt it!
 

KFunk

Psychic refugee
Joined
Sep 19, 2004
Messages
3,323
Location
Sydney
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
Slidey said:
Personally I follow utilitarian hedonism: we should perform the actions which maximise pleasure and minimise pain for everyone.
Aye, this is roughly the kind of system which underlies my decision to be vegetarian.
 

Kwayera

Passive-aggressive Mod
Joined
May 10, 2004
Messages
5,959
Location
Antarctica
Gender
Female
HSC
2005
emytaylor164 said:
look up in the sky on a clear night and then tell me that a bang created all the beautiful and amazing things in the world. it is too good to be created by nothing.
See, I do the exact opposite. I look at the sky, at the stars and planets and the superstructure of the galaxy, and think, "wow, this is all too amazing and beautiful to have been created by something."

"Creation" devalues and cheapens the glory and mystery of life and the universe.
 

KFunk

Psychic refugee
Joined
Sep 19, 2004
Messages
3,323
Location
Sydney
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
emytaylor164 said:
PRAYERS ARE ANSWERED
Bare minimum: read the last page or two. You'll see that I've already brought up issues with the claim. (i.e. asking 'how can the wealthy and well-off claim god as the cause of their prosperity while the poor, many of whom are religious, remain in a state of destitution?')
 

Kwayera

Passive-aggressive Mod
Joined
May 10, 2004
Messages
5,959
Location
Antarctica
Gender
Female
HSC
2005
emytaylor164 said:
The way i see it is something has to be out there
This is where you are wrong. There doesn't HAVE to be "something out there". Whether there is or isn't in this case is immaterial - there is nothing in the workings of the universe that REQUIRES "something to be out there".
 
Joined
Dec 10, 2006
Messages
725
Gender
Male
HSC
2008
Kwayera said:
See, I do the exact opposite. I look at the sky, at the stars and planets and the superstructure of the galaxy, and think, "wow, this is all too amazing and beautiful to have been created by something."

"Creation" devalues and cheapens the glory and mystery of life and the universe.
I liked this:

On a clear, cold, moonless night drive out into the countryside. Find a quiet spot and lie on top of your car, looking up and out into the night sky. What do you see? Some might see romantic twinkly stars. Some might see the Glory of the Creator`s handiwork. Some might see the spirits of their ancestors looking down upon them, watching and waiting. Some might find inspiration for a poem, song or painting. I am an atheist, and (as my wife would surely testify) not a very romantic one at that; so what do I see?

Do I see rocks moving in curves, stars slowly using their fuel until they're snuffed out, life popping into a pointless existence only to be destroyed by a meaningless accident, tiny points of white light illuminating dead worlds that we will never see, galaxies flying away from each other for no good reason?
To a certain extent, yes. But there is more than that. Much more.


I see a myriad of coloured suns. Stars are not just twinkles of white. All the colours of the rainbow are up there for you to see, their hue determined by their age, size and chemical makeup. From the monstrous Supergiants like Antares, with a radius three hundred and twenty times that of our Sun, to Red Giants like Betelguese in the constellation of Orion, to brilliant White Dwarfs barely the size of Jupiter.


I see chunks of rock, iron and ice; pebbles that have been circling the Sun for a billion years, being drawn into the gravity well of our planet, plunging into the atmosphere and exploding in a streak of silent light. Lying on top of your car, you see one burn across the sky every few minutes, leaving a ghostly, glowing trail suspended miles above the cloudtops. Thousands burn up in the sky every day, their dusty remains drifting down to the ground. While you're sitting in your office, or watching Oprah, or choosing a new brand of toilet paper, ancient bits of the solar system are being violently annihilated a few miles above your head.


I see the Earth hurtling along its orbital path at sixty-seven thousand miles an hour, creating a bow-shock as it pushes through the thin gases surrounding Sol, and leaving a trail of hydrogen in its wake. Charged particles from the Sun pour into the Earths magnetic field, grounding at the North and South Poles as dancing curtains of light. I see our Moon, pock-marked and white, its rotation halted by millions of years of gravitational braking as it tried to drag our oceans around with it, washing our shores with the daily tides. Inch by inch, every year, it falls away from us.


I see the Sun itself hurtling along its orbital path around the galactic core, dragging along a shoal of planets, comets, asteroids and moons, ineffectively showering them with neutrinos. Four million tons of hydrogen are burnt in this stellar furnace every second as it performs its alchemy, breaking down light elements and rebuilding them as iron. Sudden bursts of magnetic energy release huge flares and prominences of fire, extending thousands, millions of miles into space before falling back to the surface. I see our Milky Way, just one of a hundred billion others ploughing through space in a great river of galaxies, driven by forces on a scale that the human mind can barely begin to comprehend.


I see galaxies colliding, slowly and inexorably, their contents spread so thinly that it is hard to think of it as a collision at all. On a different scale, they smash into and through each other, ripping themselves apart and sending their stars swirling off to form elongated curls and spirals, eventually settling down into new galaxies and clusters of stars.


I see space distorted by the weight of a cluster of galaxies, forming a lens hundreds of thousands of light-years across. A giant magnifying glass creating multiple images of distant stars that would otherwise be obscured by the very galaxies forming the lens.


I see millisecond pulsars - exotic objects billions of light-years away, spinning hundreds of times a second and pumping out flashes of light at a regularity that our best technology would struggle to match. I see quasars - bizarre creations throwing out more energy than the stars of a hundred galaxies combined.


I see vast glowing nebulae, huge clouds of gas slowly condensing and heating - the birthplace of stars. The universe was not formed with a fixed set of stars - they are dying and being born every day, and their planets along with them. A good pair of binoculars will show you the stellar nursery in the Orion Nebula - a glowing patch of sky that is home to newborn stars.


I see black holes spinning at unimaginable speeds, dragging the stuff of space-time around with them; warping and bending space; slowing and maybe even stopping time itself. As they spin, they pull in gases, asteroids, dust and any stars unfortunate enough to be caught by this irresistible force. The matter joins a disc spinning down into the multi-dimensional whirlpool faster and faster, until it is destroyed and releases a scream of X-rays. The lucky particles that escape are ejected from the disc as twin jets of matter travelling at speeds exceeded only by light itself.


I see binary star systems. A tiny but brilliant white dwarf and a massive but dull red star spinning around each other like mismatched ice-skaters holding hands. Spiralling closer and closer, eventually they may collide, or one will suck the life out of the other, connecting the two via a bridge of plasma and burning hydrogen. Periodically, the dwarf will take more matter than it can absorb, and vast quantities of matter and energy are thrown off in a supernova explosion, leaving the skaters to continue their dance.


I look up, and for each and every star I can see on the clearest of nights, I know that there are a million galaxies that I cannot see. Too distant and too faint, moving away from us so quickly that their light is shifted out of the tiny visible spectrum. Only seen by powerful computer-guided telescopes that can focus on a tiny patch of the sky for day after day, collecting photons one at a time. Our galaxy contains an almost incomprehensible number of stars, but this is just one galaxy of hundreds of billions just like it. We can estimate and write down the total number of stars in the universe, but it's nothing more than a number on a piece of paper. There are more stars than our imaginations are capable of dealing with.


I see Andromeda, our nearest neighbour galaxy. With the unaided eye barely a faint glow on the clearest night. The pale light falling from it into my eyes is two million years old - a shame to waste it. Humans did not even exist when it began the journey, and our entire evolution to Homo sapiens, the development of language, civilisation and science has occurred during the flight of these photons across the cold intergalactic void.


I see planets orbiting a distant sun, detectable only by the tiny wobbles they create in the motion of their host. Are they tiny burnt cinders like Mercury, or toxic hellholes like Venus? Are they cold, dead worlds like Mars or massive gas-giants like Jupiter and Saturn, with a core of metallic hydrogen protected by storms that rage for a thousand years? Are they so cold they have seas of liquid methane, or mountain ranges of frozen ammonia? Do they have deep, warm seas teeming with life - odd creatures being selected by evolution for their ability to survive out of the water, crawling up an alien beach under an alien star, the first faltering steps on stubby limbs that might be fins or might be legs?


I see stars finally exhausting their fuel and collapsing as their nuclear engines can no longer overcome the pull of their own gravity. The star falls in on itself and explodes in a catastrophic supernova, expelling iron, carbon, silicon and all the stuff of life out into the universe. (In the night sky, a star suddenly brightens until it outshines the full moon, dazzling the tiny amphibian stumping up the muddy beach.) The shock waves from this destruction compress nearby gases, starting them on the long journey that will see them condensing into hot, spinning clouds. Clouds that will eventually form new solar systems and give rise to life that can look up and out into the clear night sky. And think, and wonder, and let their minds take them on a journey that their bodies can never achieve.


Carl Sagan said, "We are made of star stuff". Religion teaches that we are Children of God, and the heavens declare His Glory. The reality is, as Rev. Chuck said, "far greater than your religion could ever allow for".


This is a godless universe and it thrills me that I have the chance to ride along with it, even if only for my few decades of awareness. Many people turn to religion saying, "But there has to be more to it all than this." To them I say, "Look around you! What more could you ask for?" In terms of Truth, Beauty and Wonder, all the worlds religions cannot compete with a clear, cold, moonless night.


We are star-stuff, you and I. We are children of the supernova and our beginnings lie in the death of a star.
 

boris

Banned
Joined
May 6, 2004
Messages
4,671
Gender
Male
HSC
2007
Dude. I just don't understand the whole 'sacrificing his son for us'.

I just don't get it!
 
Joined
Dec 10, 2006
Messages
725
Gender
Male
HSC
2008
Kwayera said:
Why?




Also Chadd, who wrote that piece? It's beautiful.
Just some internet guy, but it sounds like he had deep inspiration from Carl Sagan's pale blue dot tbh.
 

boris

Banned
Joined
May 6, 2004
Messages
4,671
Gender
Male
HSC
2007
emytaylor164 said:
well according to christian teaching Jesus is sinless and perfect. Humans on the other hand are not. the punishment for sin is death and instead of us having to go to hell for our sins he unleashed his wrath on jesus so that we will not be punished. In jewish culture they used to sacrifice animals we dont need to do that because jesus is enough for everyone
But that doesn't make any freaking sense! He's just killed a perfectly innocent guy, and we're still sinning away blissfully.

It just does not compute as a logical train of thought and makes no sense to me whatsoever. If he really was as powerful as you give him credit, he could abolish sin as we know it in a heart beat. Why doesn't he.
 

boris

Banned
Joined
May 6, 2004
Messages
4,671
Gender
Male
HSC
2007
emytaylor164 said:
well it had to come out of somewhere.
No it didn't.
It's perfectly reasonable to assume it exists purely because it exists!
 

Slidey

But pieces of what?
Joined
Jun 12, 2004
Messages
6,600
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
Schroedinger said:
But I stop my cat from killing frogs and I move snails out of the way if people will tred on them and those sorts of things.
You are awesome.
 
Joined
Dec 10, 2006
Messages
725
Gender
Male
HSC
2008
well it had to come out of somewhere.
What did? Life? We understand fairly well how life evolves into advanced forms of life once we have the existence of single celled organisms (evolution), we also have some fairly good theories regarding how we get these single celled organisms, we also have some fairly good theories regarding the creation of our planet and its atmosphere, of our sun and the galaxy, of the elements in the universe and its beginning in the big bang...

Before that? We have multi-verses which seems to be supported by the MWI of quantum physics, tentatively the academically favoured belief. We could also have some form of cyclical universe or what have you... little evidence for this of course though, but there appears no reason to posit a God and even less for any form of conscious creator.
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 9)

Top