I thought the vow was to do with his task only to kill dumbeldore and thats it but maybe not!? i just want it to be out already its killing me!Kujah said:One thing - if Draco dies, does Severus die as well? Is the Unbreakable Vow still valid?
He didn't get hit by a Killing Curse when he fell into the veil. So anything's possible.lisajf said:OH i forgot after i saw the movie i came up with an awesome theory i doubt it will be right but yeh! at the end of the 5th movie Luna says something about things have a way of coming back to you and it made me think of sirius behind the veil. Is he dead or behind the veil and going to emerge again? silly maybe but it just seemed more than just what she said it felt like there was somehting behind it
They do, but what will they teach?P_Dilemma said:you know, about someone who we don't expect becoming a teacher, i was thinking maybe one of the Weasley twins, Fred and George. You can't deny they've got a level of intelligence, even Hermione acknowledges that, and they've managed to build a successful joke-shop business with some "incredible magic"...
They could both be teachers, one doing potions, one doing transfiguration. Remember how Neville transformed into a canary by eating a custard cream? That'd amount to Transfiguration. And their joke potions show they're good a potions.
-P_D
lisajf said:That would mean the villain would prevail. an evil would win. i doubt that would happen. but maybe anything is possible
And JKR said this happened for a purpose, so maybe it has something to do with the final battle and the title?Kujah said:He didn't get hit by a Killing Curse when he fell into the veil. So anything's possible.
Yes actually i saw the movie yesterday and the moment she said that i thought - wow, that is an interesting comment, because i am sure it wasn't in the books, and i was kinda like....wonder why they put that there?lisajf said:OH i forgot after i saw the movie i came up with an awesome theory i doubt it will be right but yeh! at the end of the 5th movie Luna says something about things have a way of coming back to you and it made me think of sirius behind the veil. Is he dead or behind the veil and going to emerge again? silly maybe but it just seemed more than just what she said it felt like there was somehting behind it
If that was true, then why are they both alive at the same time?cute.asa.button said:You understand the prophecy to mean that one must live.
My understanding was that they can't both live at the same time which means that at least one must die. But from what i can tell, it didn't deny the possibility that both die. That would satisfy the need for one of them to die, which is all the prophecy required, as far as i could tell...
Yeh i agree there was definately something behind it than just about finding her own belongings. I'm confused as to whether sirius was hit by the killing curse the impression i get he did but then oters say he didnt.cute.asa.button said:Yes actually i saw the movie yesterday and the moment she said that i thought - wow, that is an interesting comment, because i am sure it wasn't in the books, and i was kinda like....wonder why they put that there?
I thought maybe they somehow knew something about the last book and it was kinda a little hint of what was to come, but then i came back to my senses and thought No that is highly highly unlikely. So yeah, i dunno, but it seemed pretty meaningful to me!
Kujah said:I did feel sympathy for him when Harry entered Snape's Pensieve and observed what his dad did to him in OoTP.
I've never liked Snape