Investigating Science Anyone? (1 Viewer)

myopic_owl22

New Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2017
Messages
7
Gender
Female
HSC
2019
Subject selection is coming up really soon (yeah, my school does things really late...), and I was wondering if I should be considering Investigating Science. I've read the syllabuses for Investigating, Physics, Biology and Chemistry and am currently under the assumption that all the societal implications of each old syllabus will be taken out, expanded and repackaged into the investigating science course.

I'm interested in the modelling, theories and cause & effect topics, but not so much with the history/ society stuff. I'm also a bit wary about the 60 hours of depth studies i'll have to do during year 11 and 12, which is double the amount other sciences require.

Since our grade will be the first to choose it, a lot of things are up in the air... is it worth the 'risk'? That is:
i) Will studying it with another science help me with that science or vice versa?
ii) Will I have enough resources (and what will be expected of me)?
iii) Will it scale well (i.e. will intelligent kids do this subject)?

I love learning scientific content and applying them to real-world situations, so I'd really like to do 6 units of science - physics, chemistry and either bio or investigating depending on who else is doing/ considering it. So anyone's opinion on this will be greatly appreciated! Thanks :)
 
Joined
Apr 3, 2015
Messages
30
Location
Sydney
Gender
Female
HSC
2019
hey, im in year 10 too... in terms of scaling i personally don't think it will scale very well. Since you asked if 'intelligent kids' will do the subject the smarties in my grade did not choose it, and the grade required to pick a course for my grade was a D whereas phys and chem were B in science,english and math so i don't think it'll be a really hard course. My friend who is just like you (really loves science) he's picked chem,bio and physics AND considering science extension - during our subject talks apparently by the end of the year they'll let us know if there will be a science extension course might wanna consider that ;)
 

myopic_owl22

New Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2017
Messages
7
Gender
Female
HSC
2019
Thanks a bunch! I'll probably stick with biology then. I'll also certainly look into any extension science courses - thanks for letting me know about them!
Best wishes for the next 2 years ahead... :)
 

myopic_owl22

New Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2017
Messages
7
Gender
Female
HSC
2019
So I had a subject selection info evening a few nights ago, and asked about extension science - turns out it's basically a re-branding of investigating science. It's a year 12 course where you pick a major (in one of the sciences) and look at the science behind the science (that is, proving theories and validating conjectures, etc) of that science.

My head teacher also said that investigating science < science extension. Basically, science extension is harder (because it's more specific) & will need more work than investigating science. It seems to be following the same template of the extension history syllabus - no new content, just understanding the inquiry process and analysing/ interpreting others (and your own) data.

With this new course in year 12 for 2019ers, the maximum science units you can do is 7.

Thought I would stick this info up on BOS for anyone who's interested in Investigating/ Extension Science. Hope it helps!
 

Sci guy

New Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2018
Messages
1
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
A bit after the event I know, but I wouldn't characterise the course as all the stuff dropped from the old syllabus at all. It essentially looks at the process of science. Although the other courses do cover this to a degree it is overshadowed by the huge amount of subject specific content. You could ask a student leaving year 11 or 12 biology about the scientific method and they would likely not be able to tell you a single thing other than the need for validity and reliability in an experiment. How one would truly go about achieving this would probably evade them other than saying repeat the experiment three times... a gross misrepresentation of the kind of repetition that is usually required. I guess there is a lot of stuff on the history and philosophy of science and how scientists came to their conclusions. But if you want to know why we don't any longer think the world is flat, the universe is eternal, foul smelling air causes disease and things burn due to phlogiston and rather appreciate that all science is built on the shoulders of scientific giants then this course should appeal to you. Saying that... how will it scale? Well only time will tell but like all courses... they only scale well if you do well in them. Do crappy in chemistry and no amount of scaling will help you... in fact it will likely have the opposite effect.
 
Last edited:

Kiara_D

New Member
Joined
Sep 19, 2022
Messages
1
Gender
Female
HSC
2022
It's been a few quite a few years since OP posted, but I'll provide a reply as a NSW HSC Investigating Science student for future viewers.

i) Will studying it with another science help me with that science or vice versa?
The Investigating Science course has helped me with other science subjects. Not content such as physics formulas, or researching the Doppler effect, but particularly the skills I.S teaches is something I often apply to my other courses. I've noticed in my other science courses, most students would be struggling with revision of science skills. Unlike them, I'd be handling exam questions like a champ because of the skills taught Investigating Science.

Investigating Science is pretty much an all-rounder science subject. It's pretty general and simple in terms of the content being taught (refraction of light - Physics, The Greenhouse Effect - Earth and Environmental Sciences, etc). However, my biggest takeaway from Investigating Science is learning how to analyse and interpret data, evaluate ethical issues surrounding subjects such as nuclear energy, organ transplants and organ donation, and studying how to conduct valid and reliable investigations. In my opinion, if you're going into a field of science requiring research, Investigating Science is one of, if not the BEST subject you can do to benefit that career. There's a reason why there's a compulsory 60* hours of depth studies :)

ii) Will I have enough resources (and what will be expected of me)?
I had to buy an Investigating Science in Focus Year 11. Did I use it a lot? Not really. My teacher provided samples of the textbook in a pdf format during the lesson for those who didn't have the textbook, alongside other resources such as articles, scientific journals, etc based on what we were studying that day. I didn't bother buying the Year 12 textbook, and for good reason because I can count the number of times we did a lesson based on the Year 12 textbook on one hand. I had a pretty relaxed teacher though, so take my words with a grain of salt. Judge how much your textbook is used in Year 11, and how often the teacher provides resources, and make a judgement from there for Year 12.

Although the syllabus is pretty easy, there is a lot of content. I would expect many resources throughout stage 6 based on the large amounts of topics you're covering. You'd be expected to bring a textbook unless the teacher says otherwise, or if the teacher is someone who provides the textbook (like mine lol).

iii) Will it scale well (i.e. will intelligent kids do this subject)?

I'll be honest. The scaling is absolute crap.

Students often take the subject to bludge. My tiny class of ten students is composed of rowdy teens. Although I have peers who want to learn, it's a pretty general group of kids who don't put in much effort.

This year, my class went on an excursion to an ANSTO facility, and we had to group with another school (with a class even smaller!). Lo and behold, the other class was similar to that of mine. I distinctly remember one kid who genuinely seemed interested in what was being taught, but he was the only one that stood out to me from his classmates mucking around. That sight pretty much solidified the idea that Investigating Science wasn't the best subject to choose for good scaling in general. If you want a great class ranking, choose Investigating Science and put in some effort. That would shoot you right up.

I can't say that every I.S class is made up of 'dumb' kids, but based on my experiences, I haven't seen many of the "intelligent" kids choose the subject. Which is honestly quite saddening considering the subject is so useful for everyday life!

===
All-in-all, I recommend I.S if you're genuinely interested in a career in Science, and the skills science teaches. It was by far one of my favourite subjects, and it is actually because of I.S that I want to pursue a career in scientific research through a BSc degree, then move up to a PhD :) I.S teaches individuals how to practise scientific processes and apply those processes to investigate relevant community, personal, and global scientific issues. Want to buy a product? How do you know it's advertisements aren't false, and how are you going to find out if that particular company's taking advantage of you as a consumer? Ever wonder why the sound of a train is higher in pitch coming towards you, and receding in pitch moving away? The subject is great to apply to real world situations if you want to be an informed individual :)

Although the scaling isn't the greatest, if you do well in stage 6, you could use those grades for early entry into a university science course, should you choose to do an ATAR pathway. Lucky for me, some of the loud kids in my class are doing non-ATAR (which is probably why they chose this subject to bludge).

Anyway, good luck to anyone completing their subject selection, future Year 12 students, and current Year 12 students undertaking their HSCs in a few weeks! I'm not too religious, but since I come from a Catholic school, God Bless 😁
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 1)

Top