MedVision ad

the current english course is a waste of time, true or false (3 Viewers)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Tulipa

Loose lips sink ships
Joined
Nov 15, 2004
Messages
1,922
Location
to the left, a little below the right and right in
Gender
Female
HSC
2005
woho said:
Of course- that's why maths is optional. No one made you or anyone else do it. If you need it, do it, if you dont, then dont!

Unlike English.
Did you not read the whole post?

You need English to communicate in everyday life and you need to be able to write an essay in university.

The whole reason it was made compulsory is for the latter point.
 

iEdd

Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2006
Messages
416
Location
NSW
Gender
Male
HSC
2008
Heh, and so the cycle of arguments begins again...

You have made your point, different subjects are good for different careers. If you are arguing to say that the current english course is NOT a waste of time for people heading down the writing path, then that makes sense too. So wouldn't you then agree that english (which is just literature studies) should NOT be compulsory, just as maths and science aren't?

We need english in everyday life, yes, but we do not all need literature studies for the same reasons we don't all need calculus.

Eddy11, you pretty much summed up my thoughts in your last post.
 

Jachie

it ain't easy being white
Joined
Jun 30, 2006
Messages
1,662
Gender
Female
HSC
2008
No. There is a reason why English is compulsory and others aren't. If you honestly can’t appreciate how a subject like English forces you to justify your opinions and arguments and helps you develop the best, most succinct ways of expressing yourself, then it’s no wonder you hate the subject so much because you must be fucking stupid.

You may not like HOW the HSC English course does things (ie through analyzing texts) but the skills developed by it will be beneficial to you in later life, even if you can't realize this now. You're not going to be able to get through university unless you know how to write an essay, develop a thesis, back up your opinions, and efficiently get through readings. And THAT is why English is the only compulsory subject.
 

Captain Gh3y

Rhinorhondothackasaurus
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Messages
4,153
Location
falling from grace with god
Gender
Male
HSC
2005
That's still not quite right :D

Whether HSC English teaches you to "write essays" or not depends a lot on the teacher (we were never taught how to write essays as such, they just told us our attempts were really bad).

The overall purpose of HSC English is not to teach you to be a better writer, let alone a better communicator. It also isn't to broaden your vocabulary or inspire a love of literature, although it may do those things.

It especially isn't about communicating in every day life. In fact it's the complete opposite. See up until the end of year 10 English involves, as you may recall, every day stuff. Discerning the meaning of texts and to a limited extent, how that meaning is constructed. That's every day stuff.

The whole point of HSC English is to get you into Formal 1 (read Jean Piaget) thinking that you use all the time at uni. In other words, abstraction. It goes away from what you use in real life.

The fact that it's compulsory is just a reflection of the cynical nature of the Board of Studies. It keeps the fobs from dominating worse than they already do, to put it honestly.

EDIT: Actually this only applies to Advanced, if you don't like that shit just do Standard.

EDIT2: The moral of the story is, if you're going to do anything other than pure maths at uni, do your fucking English study.
 
Last edited:

simonloo

may our bodies remain
Joined
Jun 21, 2006
Messages
888
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
Captain Gh3y said:
The fact that it's compulsory is just a reflection of the cynical nature of the Board of Studies. It keeps the fobs from dominating worse than they already do, to put it honestly.
I agree.
 

iEdd

Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2006
Messages
416
Location
NSW
Gender
Male
HSC
2008
Jachie said:
...because you must be fucking stupid.
If english is so helpful why can't you comprehend? :wave:
 
Last edited:

Charity F

póg mo thóin
Joined
Aug 24, 2007
Messages
169
Gender
Undisclosed
HSC
N/A
iEdd said:
... We need english in everyday life, yes, but we do not all need literature studies for the same reasons we don't all need calculus....
True, i suppose.

However, as an English-speaking country, i understand why English might be compulsory and Maths is not. We should remember, that these are decisions that board memebers or ministers or whoever makes these decisions are making, by taking into account figures and information about what is happening around the entire state.

I think the main reason (that no one has addressed yet, i think) is that they force us to go through this system because there should be at least some sort of uniformity throughout the state. sort of. Otherwise there'll be complaints that an entire generation doesn't know about all this 'stuff'...

I think the best thing that i have gotten out of english is the study of all the various texts throughout the years... It makes me feel like i know something about at least a few widely appreciated texts... I mean, seriously, it's not like I'd willingly pick up Thomas More's "Utopia" or Franz Kafka's "The Trial" or Shakespeare's "Othello" if i didn't HAVE to.

in retrospect, i don't think i've made a point here... But one thing for which English can take all the credit is for widening my vocabulary, and my ability to write anything.

Say you had to do a eulogy, or you had to convince a whole lot of important people to invest in your company, etc etc. How would you do it? Would you be able to?

English does help us structure our arguments, and stimluate our minds into drawing our own conclusions and opinions, and express our ideas succinctly.

But then again maybe English isn't for everyone. i dunno, i don't really have any serious objections, because i'd still have chosen it even if it wasn't compulsory.
 

iEdd

Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2006
Messages
416
Location
NSW
Gender
Male
HSC
2008
Fair enough. :)
Charity F said:
Say you had to do a eulogy, or you had to convince a whole lot of important people to invest in your company, etc etc. How would you do it? Would you be able to?
I think so. I've never had any trouble writing essays, papers, speeches, reports in any subject other than english.
Your points are valid, which is why english (both standard and advanced) need a new direction. Writing styles to present arguments and things like that without having to be about techniques within a theme within a text. I just think the course would benefit from a broader spectrum of writing and arguing, etc so that it would be a lot more helpful for ANY career. The main problem with it right now (at my school at least) is that rewriting the teacher's ideas (which have been discussed to death) is what gets you the marks.
 

Jachie

it ain't easy being white
Joined
Jun 30, 2006
Messages
1,662
Gender
Female
HSC
2008
EDIT2: The moral of the story is, if you're going to do anything other than pure maths at uni, do your fucking English study.
That's pretty much what I've been saying :(

iEdd said:
If english is so helpful why can't you comprehend? :wave:
Um yeah, I reiterate:

Jachie said:
you must be fucking stupid.
why can't you comprehend? :wave:

EDIT: yeah this argument has really gone off-base eh :eek: MORAL OF THE STORY: STOP YR BITCHING AND DO YR HOMEWORK K
 
Last edited:

simonloo

may our bodies remain
Joined
Jun 21, 2006
Messages
888
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
Finally a post that is on topic. Interesting article.
 

iEdd

Member
Joined
Sep 25, 2006
Messages
416
Location
NSW
Gender
Male
HSC
2008
Captain Gh3y said:
I'll say.

cs01001 said:
http://www.smh.com.au/news/national/...067367877.html

Can't agree more on 'Graham Little, who wrote the 1972 NSW English syllabus for years 7 to 10, told the meeting the Department of Education's current English syllabus was "garbage"'.
Nice find, neither can I. :)
 

beentherdunthat

Active Member
Joined
Feb 28, 2006
Messages
1,132
Gender
Female
HSC
2007
AOS isn't as interesting as it could be. Huck finn is a good book though.

Creative writing questions SUCK.

Modules are fairly good. The ones im doing are pretty good anyway ;)
 

Forbidden.

Banned
Joined
Feb 28, 2006
Messages
4,436
Location
Deep trenches of burning HELL
Gender
Male
HSC
2007
beentherdunthat said:
AOS isn't as interesting as it could be. Huck finn is a good book though.

Creative writing questions SUCK.

Modules are fairly good. The ones im doing are pretty good anyway ;)
I'm with you on that.
Except my AOS text is the play 'Away' by Michael Gow.
 

benilic

New Member
Joined
Aug 23, 2006
Messages
9
Location
Canberra
Gender
Male
HSC
2007
i dont think the HSC english itself is a waste of time but if any other schools have teachers like mine you start to entertain the thought that what you are doing has no future and that what you have attempted to learn is futile.

My school has a HOD that no other teacher likes. she also happens to set most of the assessment tasks, of which our first was worth the most at 25% when we hadnt even come to understand the course. Added to this, 3 classes have had several teachers this year, one is onto its 4th teacher so far! someone needs to shape up or ship out!

our HOD for drama just resigned after a petition from the year....could be a good option with english to give the next year a chance.
 

Captain Gh3y

Rhinorhondothackasaurus
Joined
Aug 10, 2005
Messages
4,153
Location
falling from grace with god
Gender
Male
HSC
2005

evilchello5

New Member
Joined
Sep 2, 2007
Messages
6
Gender
Female
HSC
2008
its not that bad.. i have other subjects that are way worse... like in english this yr we did "all quiet on the western front" for aggression, "the crucible" for drama and watever and then just recently did "kath and Kim" for humour.... i was a bit bummed at first but it will get beta
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 3)

Top