Compulsory uni service fees to be reintroduced (2 Viewers)

Do you support VSU?

  • Yes, VSU should stay

    Votes: 18 64.3%
  • No, VSU should go

    Votes: 10 35.7%

  • Total voters
    28

banco55

Active Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2005
Messages
1,577
Gender
Male
HSC
2006
I dont agree much at all old friend. The fee aligns well with tax we'll all later pay, if we're not already. It provides a safe environment to lobby for how we want these pooled funds used for the collective benifit. It allows us to apply these valuable lessons not only to state and federal political campaigns, but also to other interactions with authority. It makes us demand more quality, earlier on. This in turn breeds better authority!
Funny you should mention "quality". I suspect that the lack of competence in administering the funds and some of the stupid stuff the funds were spent on didn't help the left's image in the CSU days.
 

withoutaface

Premium Member
Joined
Jul 14, 2004
Messages
15,098
Gender
Male
HSC
2004
IDK, I remembered Kate Ellis/someone saying we could exclude our money being spent for political purposes and all that shit.

True?
It's all just so much accounting. If the Uni has a pool of $x for student organisations and gets $y of that through compulsory fees, it can still give $(x-y) to the SRC and it won't matter.
 

Iron

Ecclesiastical Die-Hard
Joined
Jul 14, 2004
Messages
7,765
Gender
Male
HSC
2004
I still don't see how me paying to "forcibly interact" with people I don't like is going to make me want to interact with them anymore than if I didn't pay. Like, if I have to be civil I will.. But I just do not comprehend how paying to do it is going to make me resent them less.

Do not compute.
Because it allows you the chance to defeat them and their ideas? It does you both a favour by polishing your debating skills? The free market is applied to politics, instead of a apathetic competition between two stale and sluggish parties
 

katie tully

ashleey luvs roosters
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
5,213
Location
My wrist is limp
Gender
Female
HSC
2005
I would hate to go to ANU it would seem.

At CSU, we don't much care for the Ag students. But we tolerate them because they get drunk and do unusual things to each other/inanimate objects/animals. Not being made to pay the union hasn't made us less tolerant towards them. ;)

I think I understand though... If we're made to pay money, we're going to feel begrudged to participate in some social activities to feel as though we're getting something for our $$$???
 
X

xeuyrawp

Guest
The fee aligns well with tax we'll all later pay, if we're not already. It provides a safe environment to lobby for how we want these pooled funds used for the collective benifit. It allows us to apply these valuable lessons not only to state and federal political campaigns, but also to other interactions with authority. It makes us demand more quality, earlier on.
I agree almost 100%!

This in turn breeds better authority!
Disagree. Maybe it's because I've dealt with some of the worst examples of student leaders on Earth (Asians with Victor Ma, and idiotic gays who have one agenda), but in my experience, the money is just wasted as there is zero ownership.

It's exactly the same situation as public housing - people don't look after it because they don't own it, there's no psychological/emotional/financial view that "this is mine, I'll look after it". With CSU, people just say "hoorah, moneys!"
 

katie tully

ashleey luvs roosters
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
5,213
Location
My wrist is limp
Gender
Female
HSC
2005
Because it allows you the chance to defeat them and their ideas? It does you both a favour by polishing your debating skills? The free market is applied to politics, instead of a apathetic competition between two stale and sluggish parties
But
Iron
I don't much care for student politics and neither do 99% of university students. Bar a handful of people (who are going to be involved, with or without compulsory student unionism), nobody else cares. Seriously, it's not such a foreign concept to understand.

Some people go to uni to further their education. Nothing else.

Shocking. I know.
 

Iron

Ecclesiastical Die-Hard
Joined
Jul 14, 2004
Messages
7,765
Gender
Male
HSC
2004
Funny you should mention "quality". I suspect that the lack of competence in administering the funds and some of the stupid stuff the funds were spent on didn't help the left's image in the CSU days.
For sure! That's why I think that the basic problem with this is that the right has dropped the ball, so now they've taken it and gone home. I hate the status quo of Labor-right members swanning through student politics, never being seriously challenged, and coming out the other end as the most experienced young leaders in the country.
Wecandobetter,wemustdobetterandwewilldobetterTHANKYOUArndGodBless
 
X

xeuyrawp

Guest
But
Iron
I don't much care for student politics and neither do 99% of university students. Bar a handful of people (who are going to be involved, with or without compulsory student unionism), nobody else cares. Seriously, it's not such a foreign concept to understand.

Some people go to uni to further their education. Nothing else.

Shocking. I know.
I really really really think that this is a reflection of his context, Katie.
 

katie tully

ashleey luvs roosters
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
5,213
Location
My wrist is limp
Gender
Female
HSC
2005
I think if he wants to buy his way into having a say, go nuts... But does that not defeat the purpose of politics?

Tainted milK! Alert the authorities! But the authorities are Chinese :(:(:(
 

Iron

Ecclesiastical Die-Hard
Joined
Jul 14, 2004
Messages
7,765
Gender
Male
HSC
2004
I agree almost 100%!


Disagree. Maybe it's because I've dealt with some of the worst examples of student leaders on Earth (Asians with Victor Ma, and idiotic gays who have one agenda), but in my experience, the money is just wasted as there is zero ownership.

It's exactly the same situation as public housing - people don't look after it because they don't own it, there's no psychological/emotional/financial view that "this is mine, I'll look after it". With CSU, people just say "hoorah, moneys!"
But that's why we have yearly elections? Granted, they probably dont have a deep sense of committment to the well-being of university students, but they care a hell of a lot about their reputation and impending career
 

Iron

Ecclesiastical Die-Hard
Joined
Jul 14, 2004
Messages
7,765
Gender
Male
HSC
2004
But
Iron
I don't much care for student politics and neither do 99% of university students. Bar a handful of people (who are going to be involved, with or without compulsory student unionism), nobody else cares. Seriously, it's not such a foreign concept to understand.

Some people go to uni to further their education. Nothing else.

Shocking. I know.
This is fine for the accountant or the engineer - those who are bound to be the pawns of greater designs - but think of the doctors and lawyers and arts students. Spare a thought for those who will soon be entrusted to not just stoke the engine of society, but take the wheel. They are screaming bloody murder for this experience.

The tradition of retail politics like this is older than ancient Greece and we are robbing the next generation of its chance to hone its leadership skills. Rather, any old vested-interest tart will be slapped in front of a camera - as long as their dress/suit is beautiful, their teeth white and hair well done, the plebs will buy it.

Palin2012! Woo, the West Will Rise Again
 

katie tully

ashleey luvs roosters
Joined
Jun 15, 2008
Messages
5,213
Location
My wrist is limp
Gender
Female
HSC
2005
It doesn't cost money for the artfags, doctors and lawyers to sit in a circle jerk and argue politics. And if it does, and if that's their prerogative, they should feel free to pass the hat around.

I don't wear hats.
 

Iron

Ecclesiastical Die-Hard
Joined
Jul 14, 2004
Messages
7,765
Gender
Male
HSC
2004
Yes but the financial incentive forces all potential leaders out of the woodwork. It offers redemption to the politically minded who commit the sin of a commerce degree. Without this incentive, our talent pool is left to stagnate.
See communism

Also Hitler would probably have had an opinion on this, one way or another
HE wore hats
 

banco55

Active Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2005
Messages
1,577
Gender
Male
HSC
2006
This is fine for the accountant or the engineer - those who are bound to be the pawns of greater designs - but think of the doctors and lawyers and arts students. Spare a thought for those who will soon be entrusted to not just stoke the engine of society, but take the wheel. They are screaming bloody murder for this experience.

The tradition of retail politics like this is older than ancient Greece and we are robbing the next generation of its chance to hone its leadership skills. Rather, any old vested-interest tart will be slapped in front of a camera - as long as their dress/suit is beautiful, their teeth white and hair well done, the plebs will buy it.

Palin2012! Woo, the West Will Rise Again
I'm still not sure if you are being entirely serious but in any case I think you can make a good argument that student politics is NOT a good preparation for political office. It's a very cloistered world with issues that have little resonance outside uni (as Pwaryuex mentioned gay rights takes up an inordinate amount of the student politics agenda). If you were a budding politician you'd learn much more relevant skills through toastmasters (ability to speak without notes, rhetorical skills etc.). If you think handing out how to vote sheets in the uni quadrangle and arguing with butch lesbians about whether or not $100 000 should be pissed away on sending them to conferences on "lesbians in the public sphere" is a good use of union money is going to give you the skills to talk to a building labourer about the economy/mortgage rates you are kidding yourself.
 

Will Shakespear

mumbo magic
Joined
Mar 4, 2006
Messages
1,186
Gender
Male
HSC
2013
the fact is, real politics has a very real impact on our lives as citizens

student politics has NO impact on our lives as students

until that changes (and it won't), the general student population will NEVER give a shit
 

jb_nc

Google "9-11" and "truth"
Joined
Dec 20, 2004
Messages
5,391
Gender
Male
HSC
N/A
Gay rights.

Rights of gays.
 

Iron

Ecclesiastical Die-Hard
Joined
Jul 14, 2004
Messages
7,765
Gender
Male
HSC
2004
I'm still not sure if you are being entirely serious but in any case I think you can make a good argument that student politics is NOT a good preparation for political office. It's a very cloistered world with issues that have little resonance outside uni (as Pwaryuex mentioned gay rights takes up an inordinate amount of the student politics agenda). If you were a budding politician you'd learn much more relevant skills through toastmasters (ability to speak without notes, rhetorical skills etc.). If you think handing out how to vote sheets in the uni quadrangle and arguing with butch lesbians about whether or not $100 000 should be pissed away on sending them to conferences on "lesbians in the public sphere" is a good use of union money is going to give you the skills to talk to a building labourer about the economy/mortgage rates you are kidding yourself.
Why? If you cant convince fellow students that 100k on 'Lesbians in the public sphere' is folly, then what experience, or right, do you have to talk about the economy to fellow Australians? If you couldnt persuade students when you were a student, how dare you try to persuade the vast range of working families when youre an adult. It's an insult to our intelligence and a denigration of the quality of our democracy

Toastmasters is all good and well, but all universities have debating societies that should be well funded by fellow students. My point is that the debate should have a direct and immediate application to the individual - not a trifling affair soley, casually concerned with improving communication skills. There must be actual, relevant application to everyday life.

the fact is, real politics has a very real impact on our lives as citizens

student politics has NO impact on our lives as students

until that changes (and it won't), the general student population will NEVER give a shit
Students will care when we have their monies - that's the impact on their lives. Until then, untold talent is lying dormant - flowers rotting off the stem
 
Last edited:

Iron

Ecclesiastical Die-Hard
Joined
Jul 14, 2004
Messages
7,765
Gender
Male
HSC
2004
Theft is an unkind word. It's an investment in the quality and vitality of our democracy, plain and simple and I applaud it
 

Users Who Are Viewing This Thread (Users: 0, Guests: 2)

Top